In the game
The player has no army and no wages to offer. Every clan decides each season whether to send people, and the design intent is that this decision is driven by several motives that the player can feed but never fully control.
- Reward. Feasts, meat shares and beer are the direct payment. A clan compares what it was promised with what it received; the difference moves Trust up or down.
- Ancestors. Clans that have placed remains or memorial objects at the site gain a lasting Attachment and return even in lean years.
- Emblems. Granting a clan its animal on a pillar gives a large one-time boost — and makes rival clans demand the same.
- The sacred. Ceremonies at solstices and at pillar-raisings raise everyone's willingness for a season. The game does not specify what is worshipped.
- Marriage. Gatherings are where partners from other clans are found. Marriage ties between two clans make both more reliable.
- Reputation. Clans that work are honoured in song; free-riders lose standing.
Planned risks: feast fatigue (each feast must match the last), jealousy between clans, and the temptation to promise more than the Stores can cover. If Trust collapses, the project does not end with a revolt — people simply stop coming.
Historical basis
The model best supported by evidence is the work feast: labour mobilised by generous hospitality, as recorded ethnographically in many societies.1 At Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) the enclosure fills contain very large quantities of wild animal bone, there are thousands of grinding tools, and large limestone vessels may have held beer, though that last point remains preliminary.2
Ritual clearly mattered. Three skull fragments carry deliberate carved grooves, evidence of a special treatment of the dead that the researchers describe as a form of skull cult — whether of venerated ancestors or displayed enemies cannot be decided.3 The central T-pillars have arms, hands and belts and so represent human-like beings; Klaus Schmidt saw them as supernatural, but calling them "gods" goes beyond the evidence.
The enclosures also differ in their animals: snakes dominate in Enclosure A, foxes in B, boars in C, with a more varied range in D. One suggestion is that these were emblems of different groups, yet "totem" is an interpretive label, not a finding.4 Ethnographic accounts of megalith-hauling in Indonesia show that large numbers may take part for social and ritual reasons rather than strict need.5 Exogamy and marriage exchange at gatherings are an anthropological analogy; there is as yet no direct evidence for them at Taş Tepeler.
Open questions
- Did people come willingly, or were there obligations and pressures that we cannot see?
- Do the different animals in each enclosure identify social groups, or do they belong to stories told there?
- Were the honoured dead ancestors of the builders, and did all groups share them?
- Could feasting on this scale be sustained without creating lasting inequality between hosts and guests?
Related
- How do you persuade a hundred clans?
- Feasting, beer and labour
- Are the pillars people?
- Clans
- Law and custom
- The brewer
Footnotes
-
Dietler, M. & Hayden, B. (eds) 2001, Feasts: Archaeological and Ethnographic Perspectives on Food, Politics, and Power. ↩
-
Dietrich, O. et al. 2012, Antiquity 86. ↩
-
Gresky, J., Haelm, J. & Clare, L. 2017, Science Advances 3(6). ↩
-
Peters, J. & Schmidt, K. 2004, Anthropozoologica 39(1). ↩
-
Dietrich, O. 2016, "How did they do it?", The Tepe Telegrams, citing Hoskins 1986 on Kodi, West Sumba. ↩