In the game
In the planned design every adult is a generalist who can hunt, gather, carry water and pull on a rope. A role is a trained emphasis on top of that: the person still eats and hauls like everyone else, but is noticeably better at one thing and can teach it.
| Role | Does | Trains from |
|---|---|---|
| Knapper | Turns flint and obsidian into tools | Any adult |
| Carver | Quarries, shapes and decorates stone | Knapper |
| Hunter | Supplies meat, hides, feast surplus | Any adult |
| Gatherer | Supplies cereals, nuts, fibre; grinds | Any adult |
| Elder | Holds memory, settles disputes | A master of any role, with age |
| Sky-watcher | Keeps the calendar | Elder or hunter |
| Brewer | Turns grain and water into feast drink | Gatherer |
| Envoy | Carries feasts, gifts, marriages, rituals | Hunter or an elder's kin |
Skill is planned in three steps: novice, practised, master. Advancement costs seasons spent working beside a master, during which neither produces at full rate. The intended tension is that a small clan cannot afford many specialists: each person pulled out of food-getting must be fed by the rest. Large gatherings relax that limit for a few weeks, which is when masters from different clans can meet and teach. Losing a master to accident or old age before an apprentice is ready is the role system's main risk.
Historical basis
None of these roles is attested as a profession. No workshop at these sites has been tied to a class of full-time specialists, and nothing shows that anyone lived from carving or brewing alone. The roles group activities that certainly took place: flint was knapped, limestone quarried and carved, gazelle hunted, cereals gathered and ground, and people and goods moved between sites.
What can be argued is skill. UNESCO's statement on Göbeklitepe says the pillars are "believed to bear witness to the presence of specialized craftsmen, and possibly the emergence of more hierarchical forms of human society".1 The quality and consistency of the reliefs suggest practised hands, and the DAI team describes the site's grinding tools as standardised and efficient.2 Open areas between houses at Late PPNB Gürcütepe served as work areas, with half-finished limestone figurines among the finds.3 Skilled part-time work during seasonal gatherings fits this evidence at least as well as full-time specialists do.
"Sky-watcher" and "brewer" rest on the thinnest ground; their own pages name the specific finds and the objections.
Open questions
- Were skilled carvers fed by others while they worked, and for how long each year?
- Was skill passed down within families, within clans, or at the gatherings?
- Did women and men do different work? The imagery is strongly male; the labour evidence is silent.
- Does "more hierarchical" society follow from monuments, or is it read into them?