TT
tr

Game wiki · Problems to solve

Communication without writing

Runners, smoke and fire, tally sticks and tokens, memorised verse, seasonal gatherings and shared symbols: how a message crosses 100 km and survives a year when nobody can write it down.

Last edited 3 min readGame in development — design intent

Wiki pages

In the game

Every instruction the player gives is meant to travel at walking speed. A clan 60 km away hears of a planned quarrying season only when an envoy reaches it, and answers only when the envoy returns. The design goal is that the map shows what the player last heard, not what is true now.

Planned channels, each with a cost and a limit:

  • Runners and envoys carry detailed messages but tire, need food on the road and can be delayed by weather.
  • Smoke and fire signals between hilltops are fast but carry only one pre-agreed meaning ("come now", "danger").
  • Tally sticks and tokens record counts — labour-days owed, shares promised — and protect Trust when memories differ.
  • Oral mnemonics (verse, song, genealogies) store rules and plans; they cost Knowledge to compose and an elder to maintain.
  • Seasonal gatherings reset everyone's information at once and are the only place for complex agreements.
  • Carved symbols give a clan a lasting, visible claim.

A Message Fidelity value falls with distance and with each retelling. Low fidelity produces concrete failures: a clan arrives a month late, brings flint instead of food, or believes it was promised more than it was.

Historical basis

The best evidence is for shared symbols. The same repertoire of signs and animals — snakes, scorpions, birds, abstract marks — occurs on pillars, small stone plaquettes and shaft straighteners at Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) and at sites across Upper Mesopotamia, which the excavators read as a common symbolic world linking communities over a wide region.1 Projectile-point styles with different regional distributions and obsidian from distant sources both occur at Göbeklitepe, and the team has suggested that people gathered there from a radius of roughly 200 km.2 The Sayburç bench relief shows that images could be combined into a scene that tells a story.3

These signs are not writing: nothing shows that they recorded speech. Small clay tokens, argued by Denise Schmandt-Besserat to be counters for goods and a distant precursor of cuneiform, appear at Near Eastern sites from about 8000 BCE; her interpretation of the earliest plain tokens as an accounting system is debated.4 Runners, smoke signals and tally sticks are taken from ethnography and leave little or no trace; no direct evidence for them exists at Taş Tepeler.

Open questions

  • Did the repeated signs carry fixed meanings that outsiders could read, or were they understood only with a spoken explanation?
  • How were gatherings scheduled — by the moon, by seasonal events such as the gazelle migration, or by messengers?
  • Were counts of labour or food ever recorded on perishable materials such as notched wood or knotted cord?
  • How far did one person's knowledge of the wider network actually reach?

Footnotes

  1. Dietrich, O. et al. 2012, Antiquity 86. ↩

  2. "Who built Göbekli Tepe?", The Tepe Telegrams, 2016. ↩

  3. Özdoğan, E. 2022, "The Sayburç reliefs: a narrative scene from the Neolithic", Antiquity 96. ↩

  4. Schmandt-Besserat, D., "The Evolution of Writing", University of Texas at Austin. ↩

See also

Sources

  1. [1]Dietrich, O., Heun, M., Notroff, J., Schmidt, K. & Zarnkow, M.. The role of cult and feasting in the emergence of Neolithic communities. New evidence from Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey. Antiquity 86 (2012)
  2. [2]Schmandt-Besserat, D.. The Evolution of Writing. University of Texas at Austin
  3. [3]Who built Göbekli Tepe?. The Tepe Telegrams (DAI Göbekli Tepe research staff) (2016)
  4. [4]Özdoğan, E.. The Sayburç reliefs: a narrative scene from the Neolithic. Antiquity 96 (2022)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp
No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…