TT
tr

Question 14 · Open question

Was there a shared symbolic language across the Taş Tepeler sites?

T-shaped pillars, snakes, leopards, foxes and men holding their phalluses recur from site to site, and the same signs travel on small portable objects. Is this one symbolic system, a family of local traditions, or even a step towards writing?

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • AOne symbolic world

    The communities of the region shared myths, rituals and a canon of images. The pillar sites are expressions of a single cultural and religious sphere.

  • BDialects and emblems

    A common stock of motifs was used differently by each community, and perhaps by each group within a community, to mark who they were.

  • CA notation system

    Standardised signs and combinations stored knowledge for those trained to read them and stand near the beginning of the road to writing.

  • DShared world, not shared meaning

    People who hunted the same animals in the same hills would carve them without sharing any doctrine. Similar pictures need not mean similar beliefs.

Things that keep turning up

Travel between the excavated Taş Tepeler ("Stone Hills") sites and certain things repeat. There is the T-shaped pillar, which at Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) and Nevalı Çori is shown by its carved arms and hands to be a stylised body. There are snakes, foxes, boars, leopards, vultures and cranes. There are male figures who grasp their own phalluses: on the Sayburç bench, and apparently on the statue from Urfa's Yeni Mahalle. There are abstract signs, among them the H-shaped symbol and crescents that appear on the great central pillars.

The repetition is not confined to architecture. The German Archaeological Institute team has pointed out that the same animals and signs, in the same combinations, appear on stone bowls, shaft straighteners and palm-sized plaques, and that comparable pieces come from contemporary sites well beyond the Urfa hills, on the Syrian Euphrates and the upper Tigris.

That much is observation. The argument is over what kind of sharing it represents.

A common canon

The strong reading holds that these communities lived in one symbolic world. Trevor Watkins has written of far-reaching networks through which early Neolithic groups exchanged not only obsidian but ideas, and in which monumental building and imagery were ways of holding large communities together. On this view a visitor from one pillar site would have understood the buildings of another, much as a medieval traveller could read a church in a foreign town.

Or local accents

The evidence also resists a single code. Within Göbeklitepe each large enclosure favours different animals, which the excavators have tentatively linked to different groups. Between sites the differences are larger. Karahantepe has a chamber of phallic pillars watched by a stone head. Sayburç gives us something close to a scene with a story, on a bench in a building within a settlement. Researchers have remarked that human figures are more prominent in the recently excavated sites than at Göbeklitepe, though whether that reflects date, function or chance of discovery is unsettled.

A caution about pictures

It is easy to over-read likeness. People who hunt in the same hills meet the same animals. Snakes and scorpions are dangerous everywhere, and vultures gather wherever there is carrion. Some resemblance is to be expected without any shared doctrine. The convincing links are the arbitrary ones: the T shape, which copies nothing in nature, the conventions for drawing hands and belts, and specific pairings of sign with sign.

What would settle it?

A complete, published catalogue of motifs by site, building and date would let anyone test whether combinations recur more often than chance allows. Tight chronology would show whether differences between sites are regional or simply earlier and later. And finding the same unusual composition, not just the same animal, at two distant sites would be strong evidence for a transmitted story.

One language, many dialects, or just neighbours carving what they saw? Make the case for your reading.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    The T-shaped pillar itself

    Pillars of the same T form, some with arms, hands and belts carved in relief, stand at Göbeklitepe, Nevalı Çori, Karahantepe, Sayburç and other sites in the Urfa region. The form is the clearest shared convention of all.

    Schmidt 2010; Karul 2021; Özdoğan 2022

  • Evidence

    The same themes at Sayburç

    A bench relief found in 2021 shows a man facing a bull and, beside them, a frontal male figure holding his phallus between two leopards. Dangerous animals and emphatic maleness are themes also familiar from Göbeklitepe.

    Özdoğan 2022, Antiquity

  • Evidence

    Signs that travel

    Stone vessels, shaft straighteners and small plaques carry animals and abstract signs, and combinations of them, that match those on the pillars. Similar objects are known from contemporary sites across Upper Mesopotamia.

    DAI Tepe Telegrams 2017; Notroff et al. 2017

  • Counter-evidence

    Different buildings, different animals

    At Göbeklitepe the snake prevails in Enclosure A, the fox in B, the boar in C, and birds are prominent in D. Variation inside one site warns against assuming a single uniform code.

    Peters and Schmidt 2004; DAI Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Hypothesis

    Early signs as proto-writing?

    It has been proposed that repeated sign combinations on plaques and pillars worked as a notation that fixed meaning, a forerunner of hieroglyphic systems. Most specialists regard the signs as symbols and emblems, not as writing that records language.

    Morenz and Schmidt 2009

  • Counter-evidence

    Karahantepe goes its own way

    One rock-cut chamber at Karahantepe holds a group of phallus-shaped pillars and a human head carved from the bedrock wall, an arrangement without a known match at Göbeklitepe. Shared themes were clearly staged in local ways.

    Karul 2021

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]E. Özdoğan. The Sayburç reliefs: a narrative scene from the Neolithic. Antiquity 96(390): 1599–1605 (2022)
  2. [2]N. Karul. Buried Buildings at Pre-Pottery Neolithic Karahantepe / Karahantepe Çanak Çömleksiz Neolitik Dönem Gömülü Yapıları. Türk Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Dergisi 82: 21–31 (2021)
  3. [3]J. Peters, K. Schmidt. Animals in the symbolic world of Pre-Pottery Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey: a preliminary assessment. Anthropozoologica 39(1): 179–218 (2004)
  4. [4]Emblematic signs? On the iconography of animals at Göbekli Tepe. DAI, The Tepe Telegrams (2016)
  5. [5]Beginning social complexity during the Early Neolithic of Upper Mesopotamia: a view from Göbekli Tepe. DAI, The Tepe Telegrams (2017)
  6. [6]J. Notroff, O. Dietrich, L. Dietrich, C. L. Tvetmarken, M. Kinzel, J. Schlindwein, D. Sönmez, L. Clare. More than a vulture: A response to Sweatman and Tsikritsis. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 17(2): 57–63 (2017)
  7. [7]T. Watkins. New light on Neolithic revolution in south-west Asia. Antiquity 84(325): 621–634 (2010)
  8. [8]L. D. Morenz, K. Schmidt. Große Reliefpfeiler und kleine Zeichentäfelchen. Ein frühneolithisches Zeichensystem in Obermesopotamien. In: Non-Textual Marking Systems, Writing and Pseudo Script from Prehistory to Modern Times, Lingua Aegyptia Studia Monographica 8 (2009)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…