TT
tr

Question 05 · Open question

Do the T-pillars represent people, ancestors or supernatural beings?

Arms, hands, belts and loincloths show that the T-shaped pillars are stylised human-like bodies. Who or what those faceless figures were meant to be is one of the central open questions of the Taş Tepeler.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • ASupernatural beings

    The pillars are monumental images of otherworldly figures, possibly the earliest known depictions of deities or spirits, gathered as if in assembly (Schmidt, in cautious form).

  • BAncestors

    They represent the remembered or mythical dead of the community. The faceless form generalises the individual into an ancestor, and the treatment of skulls points the same way.

  • CEmblems of living groups

    Each pillar stands for a clan, lineage or social role, identified by its animals and insignia. The enclosure is then a picture of society, not of the beyond.

  • DNot recoverable

    Without texts the specific identity cannot be known. What can be studied is the consistent emphasis on the male body, on dangerous animals and on human-animal relations (Hodder & Meskell).

What is carved on the stone

Stand in front of one of the central pillars of Enclosure D at Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) and the T-shape resolves into a body. The upright shaft is a torso seen from the side. Two arms, bent at the elbow, run down the broad faces, and long-fingered hands meet on the narrow front, above a belt. From the belt hangs a loincloth made of a fox pelt. The horizontal bar on top is the head. UNESCO's description calls the pillars "abstract depictions of the human form".

That much is observation, first made on the pillars of Nevalı Çori and confirmed many times since. Not every pillar has arms, but the form is consistent enough that archaeologists treat the T-shape itself as a body.

The puzzle of the missing face

These figures have no faces. That is not for lack of skill. The same culture produced the "Urfa Man", a life-size statue with a face and eyes of black obsidian, and naturalistic limestone heads were found at Göbeklitepe itself. The sculptors could carve a person. For the pillars they chose not to.

The excavators drew a careful conclusion from this. Faceless, larger than life and highly abstract, the pillars seem to stand on a different level from the naturalistic statues. They may represent something beyond ordinary human beings. Klaus Schmidt spoke of beings from another world; his colleagues add that calling them "deities" would be bold, since nothing is known of the beliefs involved.

Clues from the insignia

The central pillars of Enclosure D differ in the signs on their "throats": one bears an H-shaped symbol with a disc and crescent, the other a bucranium. These look like identifiers, and the Neolithic viewer presumably knew who was meant. Similar V-shaped neckbands appear on the Urfa statue and on the human figure in the Sayburç relief, which suggests a shared convention for marking a certain kind of person or being.

Ian Hodder and Lynn Meskell approach the problem differently. Without trying to name the figures, they point to recurring themes across the region: maleness, dangerous wild animals, and the piercing and removal of flesh and heads.

What would settle it?

Nothing short of writing would name the figures, and there is none. But patterns can narrow the options. If pillars in different enclosures prove to carry consistent, distinct sets of insignia, the "social groups" reading gains ground. If human remains turn out to be regularly associated with particular pillars, the ancestors gain. New finds at Karahantepe and Sayburç, where human imagery is more explicit, are changing the picture quickly. Which reading would you defend, and what find would change your mind?

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    Arms, hands and clothing

    Some pillars carry arms in low relief down their sides, with hands meeting above the abdomen. The central pillars of Enclosure D also wear belts with fox-pelt loincloths, and garment-like bands over the shoulders.

    Schmidt 2010; Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    Always faceless

    No T-pillar has eyes, nose or mouth. The 'head' is the horizontal bar of the T; individual pillars are distinguished only by symbols placed below it, where a necklace would hang.

    Notroff, Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    The sculptors could carve realistic humans

    The life-size 'Urfa Man' statue has a face with inset obsidian eyes, and naturalistic stone heads are known from Göbeklitepe itself. The abstraction of the pillars was therefore a choice, not a limit of skill.

    Tepe Telegrams 2016; Hauptmann 2003

  • Hypothesis

    Beings of another order

    Because they are larger than life, faceless and abstract, the excavators proposed that the pillars depict something beyond ordinary humans: ancestors, mythical figures or supernatural beings. They stop short of calling them gods.

    Schmidt 2010; Notroff 2016

  • Evidence

    Carved human skulls

    Fragments of three human skulls from Göbeklitepe bear deliberate deep incisions, and one has a drilled hole. This suggests special treatment of certain dead, a possible link to ancestor veneration.

    Gresky, Haelm & Clare 2017, Science Advances 3

  • Counter-evidence

    No proof of worship

    Nothing shows that anyone prayed to the pillars. Critics note that 'god' and 'ancestor' are categories borrowed from later religions, and that the figures could stand for living social groups or roles.

    Banning 2011; Hodder & Meskell 2011

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]K. Schmidt. Göbekli Tepe – the Stone Age Sanctuaries. New results of ongoing excavations with a special focus on sculptures and high reliefs. Documenta Praehistorica 37, 239–256 (2010)
  2. [2]J. Notroff. Could we really call it a 'temple'? – The Tepe Telegrams. German Archaeological Institute (DAI) (2016)
  3. [3]Göbekli Tepe – UNESCO World Heritage Centre. UNESCO (2018)
  4. [4]J. Gresky, J. Haelm, L. Clare. Modified human crania from Göbekli Tepe provide evidence for a new form of Neolithic skull cult. Science Advances 3(6), e1700564 (2017)
  5. [5]I. Hodder, L. Meskell. A 'curious and sometimes a trifle macabre artistry': some aspects of symbolism in Neolithic Turkey. Current Anthropology 52(2), 235–263 (2011)
  6. [6]H. Hauptmann. Eine frühneolithische Kultfigur aus Urfa. In M. Özdoğan, H. Hauptmann, N. Başgelen (eds), Köyden Kente: Studies Presented to Ufuk Esin, Arkeoloji ve Sanat Yayınları, 623–636 (2003)
  7. [7]E. Özdoğan. The Sayburç reliefs: a narrative scene from the Neolithic. Antiquity 96(390), 1599–1605 (2022)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…