How the "first temple" was born
When Klaus Schmidt began excavating Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) in the mid-1990s, what he found did not look like a village. There were great round enclosures ringed with carved pillars, and little that resembled the houses, hearths and household debris known from sites such as Çayönü or Nevalı Çori. The hill is high, exposed and has no spring. Schmidt concluded that this was a sanctuary: a place where mobile hunter-gatherers met for ritual and then dispersed. His phrase "first came the temple, then the city" travelled around the world.
UNESCO's inscription text keeps part of this reading, describing monuments "probably used in connection with rituals, most likely of a funerary nature".
The first challenge: are these houses?
In 2011 the archaeologist Ted Banning questioned the whole opposition. Ethnography, he argued, shows the sacred and the everyday thoroughly mixed; Neolithic people buried their dead under house floors and painted their walls. The enclosures might be large, roofed, symbol-laden houses. The excavation team replied that Banning's general point was fair, but that the buildings matched the "special purpose buildings" found as rare exceptions in contemporary villages, and that typical domestic remains were missing.
The second challenge: the evidence changed
That last argument has weakened. Work published since 2019 documents more than 7000 grinding tools, phytoliths showing that cereals were processed in quantity, cisterns cut into the bedrock, and smaller buildings interpreted as domestic. Lee Clare's 2020 summary and the building-history studies by Moritz Kinzel and Clare no longer describe an uninhabited sanctuary. The current picture is of a settlement, occupied for many centuries, that contained exceptional buildings.
A regional pattern
The other Taş Tepeler sites help. At Karahantepe and Sayburç, communal buildings stand beside or near residential ones. Seen from there, Göbeklitepe looks less like a lonely cathedral and more like a large settlement of its region with an unusual concentration of special buildings.
What would settle it?
Full excavation of a domestic quarter contemporary with the oldest enclosures would be decisive, as would secure evidence on whether the enclosures were roofed and what was done on their floors. Micro-residue studies, more radiocarbon dates from building phases and comparison with Karahantepe are all under way or possible. In the meantime: is "temple" a useful word here, or does it mislead? Make your case, and compare it with Why were the enclosures filled in?, where the same evidence is in play.