TT
tr

ArticleEditorial draft

What is Göbeklitepe?

A mound of limestone rubble above the Harran plain holds the oldest monumental buildings yet excavated. What was found there, how old it is, and why the 'first temple' label is now under revision.

TT Living History Editorial — draft for author reviewPublished 9 min read

About 15 km north-east of Şanlıurfa, on a ridge of the Germuş range some 770 m above sea level, sits a rounded mound that local people long knew as a place with a wishing tree on top. The mound is not natural. It is roughly nine hectares of collapsed and rebuilt stone architecture, piled up over more than a millennium by people who had no pottery, no metal, and no domesticated animals. This is Göbeklitepe (also written Göbekli Tepe, "Potbelly Hill"), inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2018 as "one of the first manifestations of human-made monumental architecture".1

That phrase is carefully chosen, and so should every other sentence about the site be. Much of what is repeated about Göbeklitepe – that it was a temple, that nobody lived there, that it was buried on purpose – belongs to the first phase of research and has been revised by the excavators themselves. This article sets out what has actually been dug up, and where interpretation begins.

A hill of rubble above the plain

From the top of the mound the view runs south across the Harran plain towards Syria; to the north the Eastern Taurus are visible on a clear day. The bedrock is a pale, bedded limestone that splits naturally into slabs, and the plateaus around the mound are scarred with Neolithic quarry cuts, including pillars that were outlined in the rock and never lifted out.

The mound was first recorded in the 1960s by a joint survey of the universities of Istanbul and Chicago, which noted the dense scatter of flint on its surface but did not recognise what lay beneath.2 In 1994 the German archaeologist Klaus Schmidt, who had worked at Nevalı Çori and knew what a broken T-shaped pillar looked like, revisited the hill. Excavations began in 1995 under the German Archaeological Institute (DAI) and the Şanlıurfa Museum and have continued, with changes of direction, ever since. The story of that recognition is told in The rediscovery of Göbeklitepe.

What the excavators found

The best-known part of the site is a hollow on the south-eastern slope where four large round-oval buildings, labelled A to D, lie close together. Each has a thick ring wall of quarried stone with a bench along its inner face. Set into the wall and bench at intervals are monolithic limestone pillars shaped like a capital T; two taller pillars stand free near the centre.

Building D is the largest and the best preserved. It measures about 20 m across. Its two central pillars rise to roughly 5.5 m and are estimated at eight to ten tonnes each; they stand in shallow sockets on pedestals carved out of the bedrock floor. Eleven smaller pillars stand in the surrounding ring.

The pillars are the signature of the place. Many carry animals in low relief – foxes in Building B, snakes in A, wild boar in C, a wider bestiary in D. The central pair in Building D have arms bent at the elbow, long-fingered hands meeting above a belt, and a fox-pelt loincloth, which is why most researchers read the T-shape as a highly stylised human body. What that body stood for is a separate question, taken up in The T-pillars and what they may represent.

Around and above the big buildings are dozens of smaller ones. In Schmidt's original scheme these rectangular rooms, some with a pair of small pillars, formed a later layer. They were excavated early and studied late, and they turn out to matter a great deal.

How old is it?

Dating Göbeklitepe is harder than its fame suggests. The fill inside the buildings is a mixture of material of different ages, so a charcoal fragment from deep in the rubble does not necessarily date the wall beside it. The most direct evidence comes from organic matter trapped in the clay plaster of the ring walls. A sample from the wall of Building D gave a calibrated range of 9745–9314 BCE, placing its construction in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic A (PPNA).3

Taken together, the radiocarbon series and the typology of the projectile points put the occupation between c. 9500 and c. 8000 BCE, from the later PPNA into the middle Pre-Pottery Neolithic B. The current project team gives a slightly wider bracket, c. 9600–7750 BCE. Either way the site was in use for something like fifteen centuries – longer than the interval that separates us from the fall of Rome – and it was abandoned around the time that farming villages with domesticated crops and herds became the norm in the region.

The builders, then, were hunter-gatherers in the economic sense: the animal bones are overwhelmingly gazelle, aurochs, wild boar and wild ass, and the cereals are morphologically wild. That does not mean they were small bands of wanderers. See Who built it?.

The first reading: a sanctuary on a mountain

Schmidt's interpretation, set out in his 2006 book and many articles, was bold and coherent. The big buildings were sanctuaries, not houses. Nobody lived on the hill; there was, he argued, no water and no domestic refuse. Mobile groups from a wide region assembled periodically to quarry, carve and feast, and when a building had served its purpose they buried it deliberately in rubble. The effort of feeding such gatherings, he suggested, pushed people towards cultivating wild cereals. He compressed the argument into a slogan: first the temple, then the city.

It was a powerful idea because it reversed the textbook sequence in which farming creates surplus, surplus creates villages, and villages eventually create religion and monuments. It also rested on the evidence then available. The deposits that would later complicate the picture were either unexcavated or unstudied.

The revision since 2017

Schmidt died in 2014. The project continued under the Şanlıurfa Museum and then under Necmi Karul of Istanbul University, with Lee Clare directing research for the DAI. Two things changed the picture.

The first was the building of permanent protective shelters, completed in 2017. Their foundations required deep, narrow soundings through the mound down to bedrock. In those soundings the team met hearths, middens and working floors in the earliest deposits – the ordinary debris of people living somewhere.

The second was the study of material that had sat in storage. Laura Dietrich and colleagues examined 7,268 grinding tools from the site and showed through use-wear and phytolith analysis that most had been used to process cereals, on a scale that is unusual for the period.4 Rock-cut cisterns on the plateau, with a combined capacity of about 153 cubic metres, and channels that led rainwater towards them answered the old objection that the hill had no water.

The team now interprets the many buildings without large pillars as houses and states that people lived at Göbeklitepe throughout its history. The UNESCO description reflects the shift: it speaks of "monumental communal buildings" and of non-monumental structures that appear to be domestic.

That does not make the site ordinary. Dietrich and her co-authors themselves stress that the quantity of grinding equipment looks too large for daily household needs alone and that cistern capacity would have limited the permanent population; they continue to see large gatherings and feasting as part of the story. The disagreement is now about proportions, not about a simple either-or. The arguments on each side are laid out in Temple or settlement?.

Was it buried on purpose?

The deliberate burial of the buildings was for two decades one of the best-known "facts" about Göbeklitepe. Architectural study by Moritz Kinzel and Lee Clare has questioned it. The ring walls nearest the slope are the most damaged; several pillars lean the same way; walls were repaired and rebuilt more than once. They argue that the big buildings stood open and in use for a long time, were repeatedly hit by debris sliding down from the settlement terraces above, were patched up, and were eventually overwhelmed. On this view the animal bone in the fill is displaced settlement refuse, not the leftovers of closing feasts.

What remains unknown

Only a small part of the mound has been excavated; geophysical survey shows more large round buildings still underground. No ordinary cemetery has been found, though fragments of human skull with deliberately cut grooves indicate that the dead, or parts of them, were present in some form.5 Whether the large buildings were roofed is unresolved. So is the question of who was allowed inside them.

And Göbeklitepe is no longer alone. Since 2019, excavations at Karahantepe, Sayburç, Sefertepe and other hills around the Harran plain have shown that it was one node in a dense regional network, now studied together as Taş Tepeler. The honest answer to "what is Göbeklitepe?" is therefore a modest one: a long-lived settlement of hunter-gatherers who invested extraordinary labour in communal buildings and in an imagery of wild animals and faceless stone people – and whose reasons we are still working out.

If you plan to see it, the visitor page has the practical details; many of the portable finds are in the Şanlıurfa Archaeology Museum.

Footnotes

  1. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, list entry 1572, criterion (ii). The property was inscribed in 2018 under criteria (i), (ii) and (iv). ↩

  2. The research history is summarised on the official Taş Tepeler project page for Göbeklitepe (text by Lee Clare and Jonas Breuers), which also gives the altitude, the nine-hectare extent and the c. 9600–7750 BCE bracket used above. ↩

  3. Sample KIA-44149, discussed by Oliver Dietrich in the DAI's Tepe Telegrams ("How old is it? Dating Göbekli Tepe", 2016). The date gives the age of organic material in the plaster and is therefore a close, not an exact, indicator of when the wall was built. ↩

  4. L. Dietrich et al. 2019, PLOS ONE 14(5). The figure of 7,268 analysed grinding tools and the cistern capacity of 153 cubic metres are both taken from this paper. ↩

  5. J. Gresky, J. Haelm and L. Clare, "Modified human crania from Göbekli Tepe provide evidence for a new form of Neolithic skull cult", Science Advances 3 (2017). The authors describe three partial skulls with carved grooves. ↩

Sources

  1. [1]Göbekli Tepe – UNESCO World Heritage List, no. 1572. UNESCO World Heritage Centre (2018)
  2. [2]Lee Clare. Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. A brief summary of research at a new World Heritage Site (2015–2019). e-Forschungsberichte des DAI 2020(2): 81–88. Deutsches Archäologisches Institut (2020)
  3. [3]Moritz Kinzel, Lee Clare. Monumental – compared to what? A perspective from Göbekli Tepe. In: Gebauer, Sørensen, Teather, Valera (eds), Monumentalising Life in the Neolithic. Oxbow Books (2020)
  4. [4]Laura Dietrich, Julia Meister, Oliver Dietrich, Jens Notroff, Janika Kiep, Julia Heeb, André Beuger, Brigitta Schütt. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5): e0215214. PLOS ONE (2019)
  5. [5]Oliver Dietrich, Manfred Heun, Jens Notroff, Klaus Schmidt, Martin Zarnkow. The role of cult and feasting in the emergence of Neolithic communities. New evidence from Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey. Antiquity 86(333). Antiquity / Cambridge University Press (2012)
  6. [6]Oliver Dietrich. How old is it? Dating Göbekli Tepe (Tepe Telegrams). Deutsches Archäologisches Institut (2016)
  7. [7]Lee Clare, Jonas Breuers. Göbeklitepe – Şanlıurfa Neolithic Research Project (Taş Tepeler), site page. Republic of Türkiye Ministry of Culture and Tourism
  8. [8]Andrew Curry. Last Stand of the Hunter-Gatherers? Archaeology, May/June 2021. Archaeological Institute of America (2021)
  9. [9]Klaus Schmidt. Sie bauten die ersten Tempel: das rätselhafte Heiligtum der Steinzeitjäger. C.H. Beck (2006)
  10. [10]E. B. Banning. So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East. Current Anthropology 52(5). University of Chicago Press (2011)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…