TT
tr

Question 03 · Contested

Why were the enclosures filled in?

For two decades the great enclosures were thought to have been deliberately buried by their builders. The current excavators now attribute much of the fill to slope slides and erosion, and the debate is not over.

Published 2 min read

Competing views

  • ADeliberate ritual burial

    The builders decommissioned each enclosure by filling it with rubble and refuse, an act with symbolic meaning comparable to a funeral (Schmidt).

  • BNatural inundation by slope slides

    Erosion and slope failure, perhaps triggered by heavy rain or earthquakes, carried debris from the surrounding settlement into the enclosures. People repaired them until they gave up (Clare, Kinzel, Breuers).

  • CBoth, at different times and places

    Some deposits may be deliberate closure and others natural. The evidence from Karahantepe suggests that intentional burial was real in the region, so each building must be argued layer by layer.

The observation

Anyone who has seen photographs of the early excavations at Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) knows the image: pillars more than five metres tall emerging from a mass of fist-sized limestone rubble. That fill is the reason the enclosures survive so well. It is also a puzzle. It contains enormous quantities of flint flakes, broken tools, animal bones and pieces of sculpture, and it sits inside buildings whose walls it sometimes overtops.

The classic answer: they buried their own monuments

Klaus Schmidt concluded that the enclosures had been backfilled on purpose. In his account each building had a life: it was built, used, and finally "buried" by the community, which then raised a new one. The idea had regional support. At Çayönü and Nevalı Çori, special buildings were closed with evident care, a practice Mehmet and Aslı Özdoğan called "the cult of buildings". Deliberate burial also seemed to explain why refuse rich in feasting debris ended up inside a ritual structure.

The revision: the hill came down

From 2015 the new research team re-examined the old sections and dug deep soundings. Their conclusion, set out by Lee Clare, Moritz Kinzel and Jonas Breuers, is that much of the fill arrived without human intent. The big enclosures lie low on the slope, below areas with dense later building. When slopes failed, sediment, wall rubble and midden material from above poured into them. The team sees more than one such event, with phases of clearing, repair and the building of a terrace wall in between. On this reading, the artefacts in the fill are ordinary settlement debris from uphill, not offerings.

Why it matters

The answer changes how everything else is read. If the fill is a deliberate deposit, it may record feasts and closing ceremonies. If it is slope wash, it tells us about the settlement uphill and cannot be used to date the enclosures directly. It also bears on the end of the site: buildings repeatedly overwhelmed by debris might simply have been given up.

What would settle it?

Micromorphology, the study of sediment structure under the microscope, can distinguish dumped fill from material that flowed or washed in. So can the orientation of stones, the refitting of broken artefacts across layers, and dense radiocarbon sequences through the fill. Published results of that kind, building by building, are what is needed. Until they appear, which reading do you find more convincing, and would you expect the answer to be the same at Göbeklitepe and at Karahantepe? Continue with Why was the site abandoned?.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    Enclosures packed with rubble

    When excavated, the enclosures were full of limestone rubble mixed with flint debris, animal bone, tools and fragments of sculpture. The pillars survived to full height because they were encased in this fill.

    Schmidt 2010, Documenta Praehistorica 37

  • Hypothesis

    Ritual burial of buildings

    Klaus Schmidt interpreted the fill as intentional: at the end of their use the enclosures were 'buried' by their makers, much as a body might be.

    Schmidt 2010

  • Counter-evidence

    Slope slides from the settlement above

    The current team argues that sediment and building rubble from higher parts of the mound repeatedly slid into the lower-lying enclosures. They identify more than one such event, followed by repairs.

    Clare 2020; Kinzel & Clare 2020; Breuers & Kinzel 2022

  • Evidence

    Repairs and protective walls

    The enclosures show repeated rebuilding, and a terrace wall was built upslope of Enclosure C. This is read as an attempt by the inhabitants to keep the buildings in use and protect them from further slides.

    Kinzel & Clare 2020

  • Evidence

    Deliberate filling reported at Karahantepe

    At the sister site of Karahantepe, the excavator Necmi Karul describes buildings that were intentionally filled and whose pillars were deliberately broken or removed before burial.

    Karul 2021, Türk Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Dergisi 82

  • Evidence

    A wider tradition of 'burying' buildings

    Special buildings at Çayönü and Nevalı Çori were also carefully closed at the end of their lives. Intentional building burial is therefore a known practice in the region, whatever happened at Göbeklitepe.

    Özdoğan & Özdoğan 1998

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]K. Schmidt. Göbekli Tepe – the Stone Age Sanctuaries. New results of ongoing excavations with a special focus on sculptures and high reliefs. Documenta Praehistorica 37, 239–256 (2010)
  2. [2]L. Clare. Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. A brief summary of research at a new World Heritage Site (2015–2019). e-Forschungsberichte des DAI 2020, Faszikel 2, 81–88 (2020)
  3. [3]M. Kinzel, L. Clare. Monumental – compared to what? A perspective from Göbekli Tepe. In A. B. Gebauer et al. (eds), Monumentalising Life in the Neolithic, Oxbow Books, 31–50 (2020)
  4. [4]J. Breuers, M. Kinzel. '[…] but it is not clear at all where all the […] debris had been taken from […]': Chipped Stone Artefacts, Architecture and Site Formation Processes at Göbekli Tepe. In Y. Nishiaki, O. Maeda, M. Arimura (eds), Tracking the Neolithic in the Near East, Sidestone Press (2022)
  5. [5]N. Karul. Buried Buildings at Pre-Pottery Neolithic Karahantepe. Türk Arkeoloji ve Etnografya Dergisi 82, 21–31 (2021)
  6. [6]M. Özdoğan, A. Özdoğan. Buildings of cult and the cult of buildings. In G. Arsebük, M. Mellink, W. Schirmer (eds), Light on Top of the Black Hill: Studies Presented to Halet Çambel, Ege Yayınları (1998)
  7. [7]L. Dietrich et al.. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5), e0215214 (2019)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…