Two questions in one
"Why were the sites abandoned?" hides two different problems. The first is physical: how did the great buildings come to be full of rubble? The second is historical: why did people stop building and using them? For years the two were answered together. They are now better kept apart. A closely related page deals with the first in detail (Why were the enclosures backfilled?); this one concentrates on the second.
How the buildings ended
Klaus Schmidt believed that the people of Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) buried their own monuments. The enclosures were found packed with stone rubble, flint, animal bone and broken sculpture, and he took this to be deliberate backfilling, a ritual ending.
The current excavation team reads the same deposits differently. The buildings were dug into the flank of a mound that kept rising as people built above them. Kinzel and Clare argue that the fill is largely material from upslope that came down in slides, and that walls and pillars show signs of damage and repair. A 2026 study of the first intact burials from the site draws on the same model to explain why scattered human bone turns up in the fill.
Why nobody came back
Whatever filled the buildings, the larger fact is that the tradition faded. At Göbeklitepe the later buildings are smaller and their pillars plainer. By about 8000 BCE the mound was no longer used.
The usual explanation looks to the wider transformation of the ninth millennium BCE. Across the region, communities were coming to depend on cultivated cereals and on herded sheep and goats. At Nevalı Çori, bioarchaeological work shows people who were mobile and well connected early in the PPNB and apparently less so later on. Lee Clare has described the Taş Tepeler phenomenon as a response to a "hunter-gatherer crisis", an effort to uphold older values while the ground shifted. On that reading, the effort eventually failed, or ceased to matter.
Schmidt thought along similar lines: the belief world of hunters would have lost its meaning for communities that were becoming farmers. This is persuasive, but it is an inference from timing. Nothing at the sites records why anyone left.
Two further points complicate any simple story. First, there is no sign of catastrophe: no destruction layer, no evidence of massacre, and no abrupt climatic event known to coincide with the end. The sharp cold snap of around 6200 BCE came far too late. Second, people did not vanish from the region. Later Neolithic settlements are known on the plain near Şanlıurfa. Abandonment of the hilltops may mean a move to land better suited to fields and flocks.
What would settle it?
Dense radiocarbon series from the final phases of each Taş Tepeler site would show whether they ended together or one by one. Micromorphology of the fills would distinguish dumped from slumped sediment site by site. Excavation of late PPNB villages on the plain could show whether pillar traditions continued there in altered form. And plant and animal remains from the last layers would show how far farming had advanced when the building stopped.
Was this an ending, a failure or a move? Tell us which account you find strongest and what evidence you would look for.