The view from the ridge
Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) lies about 15 km north-east of Şanlıurfa, on a bare limestone ridge of the Germuş mountains. To the south the ground falls away to the Harran plain, which runs on towards Syria. On a clear day the mound is visible from far out on the plain, and from the mound the horizon is immense. It is a fine place to stand and an awkward place to stay: there is no spring on the hill.
Any explanation of the site has to deal with both facts.
What the landscape offered
Game. The most numerous animal in the bone assemblage is gazelle. Isotope work by Lang and colleagues showed that these animals were migratory and present near the site only seasonally, with hunting concentrated between midsummer and autumn. A ridge between plain and upland is a natural vantage point over herds on the move. The same season is when the excavators place their large gatherings.
Plants. The archaeobotanist Reinder Neef identified wild einkorn, wild barley, almond and pistachio among the sparse charred remains, a mixture he described as steppe-forest. The hills of this region still carry wild cereals, and Karacadağ, the volcano tied by geneticists to einkorn domestication, lies within a few days' walk.
Stone. The builders did not have to haul their pillars far. The plateau itself is the quarry, and flint for the tools that worked it was knapped on site in great quantity.
Water. Here the landscape gives least. The nearest seasonal stream is roughly 3 km away and the nearest spring pools about 5 km. Rock-cut cisterns on the plateau collected rain. Their dating is uncertain, and their combined capacity, 153 cubic metres, sets a limit on how many people could stay through the dry months.
The Taş Tepeler change the question
For two decades Göbeklitepe dominated the picture so completely that it seemed one of a kind, which made "why here?" a question about a single hill. The Taş Tepeler ("Stone Hills") project has since shown that sites with T-shaped pillars are scattered across the region: Karahantepe in the Tektek mountains, Sayburç beneath a modern village, and others still being explored. Many occupy limestone heights, but not all, and their settings vary.
So the better question may be "why this region?" The answer could lie in the wider pattern: a belt of hills between the Taurus foothills and the plain, rich in game, wild cereals and workable stone at the end of the Ice Age. Within that belt, which hill received the largest buildings may have depended on things archaeology cannot see, such as whose territory it was or what story was told about it.
What would settle it?
Local records of ancient springs and rainfall would show whether the hill was really as dry then as now. Secure dating of the cisterns would show whether water storage was part of the original plan. Mapping visibility between all the pillar sites would test the landmark idea. And comparable faunal and botanical studies at the other sites would show whether Göbeklitepe's gazelle season is special or ordinary.
Was this hill chosen with the heart or with the stomach? Give us your argument.