TT
tr

Question 13 · Contested

What is the link to the domestication of wheat?

Genetic studies traced domesticated einkorn to wild stands on Karacadağ, not far from Göbeklitepe, and the excavators wondered whether feeding the builders set farming in motion. But no domesticated plants have been found at the site, and many specialists now see domestication as slow and spread across the Fertile Crescent.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • AA core area near the Taş Tepeler

    The founder crops were domesticated once or a few times in a small region of south-eastern Turkey around Karacadağ, among the same communities that built the pillar sites.

  • BProtracted and dispersed

    People across the Fertile Crescent cultivated wild cereals for a millennium or more before domestic traits became fixed, in several places at once. South-east Turkey was one region among several.

  • CRitual as trigger

    Whatever the geography, the need to provision large gatherings gave people a reason to intensify cereal use. Monuments came first and farming followed.

  • DCoincidence of place

    Göbeklitepe's builders were hunter-gatherers who processed wild grain. That domestication later took hold in the wider region does not make the site its cause.

A mountain and a hill

In 1997 a team led by Manfred Heun compared the DNA of einkorn wheat lines, wild and cultivated, from across the Near East. The wild plants most closely related to the domesticated crop came from one area: the slopes of Karacadağ, a basalt volcano in south-eastern Turkey. A later study by Özkan and colleagues placed the origin of domesticated emmer in the same general region.

Karacadağ lies under a hundred kilometres from Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe). When Klaus Schmidt began to uncover monumental buildings made by people who still hunted and gathered, the coincidence was hard to ignore. Heun himself became a co-author of the 2012 paper in which the excavators suggested that the labour and feasting at the site may have helped to drive the turn to cultivation.

What Göbeklitepe itself contributes

The site's own evidence is narrower than the story often told about it.

  • The identified cereals are wild. No domesticated grain or chaff has been reported.
  • Charred plant remains are scarce and poorly preserved.
  • Cereal use was nevertheless intense. Use-wear on grinding stones and abundant cereal phytoliths show that large amounts of grain were processed.
  • The animals are wild as well, chiefly gazelle and aurochs.

So Göbeklitepe documents hunter-gatherers who relied heavily on wild cereals, at least seasonally. It does not document farming.

Where that leaves Karacadağ

The genetic observation has not gone away. Modern domesticated einkorn does resemble Karacadağ wild populations more than others. What has changed is the interpretation. On the protracted model, that resemblance tells us which wild gene pool contributed most to the lineages that survive today. It does not tell us where or when people first sowed, tended and harvested, nor that it happened only once.

The provisioning hypothesis has also been separated from the geography. One can doubt a single cradle and still think that large gatherings rewarded those who could produce more grain. Equally, one can accept a leading role for south-eastern Turkey and doubt that ritual had much to do with it. Arranz-Otaegui and colleagues add a further complication: in their survey, PPNA plant economies in the eastern part of the Fertile Crescent leaned towards legumes, nuts and fruits, which makes Göbeklitepe's cereal-heavy toolkit stand out all the more.

What would settle it?

Well-preserved, directly dated plant assemblages from the Taş Tepeler sites, with chaff that can be scored as wild or domestic type, would show what was happening locally. Weed floras could reveal whether fields were being tilled. And ancient DNA from archaeological grains, where it survives, would test the Karacadağ link against the past instead of against modern plants.

Did the monuments make the farmers, or did both grow from the same soil? Tell us which view you would defend.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    Einkorn points to Karacadağ

    DNA fingerprinting of wild and cultivated einkorn found that wild populations from the Karacadağ mountains are the closest relatives of the domesticated crop. The authors concluded that this was very probably where einkorn was domesticated.

    Heun et al. 1997, Science

  • Evidence

    Only wild cereals at Göbeklitepe

    The charred plant remains from the site are few and include wild einkorn and wild barley, with no domesticated forms. Phytoliths and thousands of grinding tools nonetheless show cereal processing on a massive scale.

    Neef 2003; Dietrich et al. 2019

  • Hypothesis

    Feeding the gatherings

    The excavators proposed that repeated large gatherings created a demand for food, and perhaps beer, that pushed people towards intensive use and eventually cultivation of wild cereals. This is a scenario, not a demonstrated causal chain.

    Dietrich et al. 2012; Schmidt 2010

  • Counter-evidence

    Domestication was slow

    Archaeological cereal remains show that non-shattering, domestic-type ears appeared gradually and that wild-type ears remained common in cultivated fields for a very long time afterwards. Cultivation long preceded domestication.

    Tanno and Willcox 2006; Weiss et al. 2006

  • Counter-evidence

    A single origin can be a statistical illusion

    Simulations show that crops with several origins can still appear, in genome-wide data, to descend from one locality. The clean Karacadağ signal therefore does not rule out a dispersed process.

    Allaby, Fuller and Brown 2008, PNAS

  • Evidence

    Regions took different paths

    A review of archaeobotanical data found that in the PPNA wild cereals were commonly cultivated in the southern-central Levant and on the Upper Euphrates, while plant use further east, including south-east Turkey, focused more on legumes, fruits and nuts. Domestic-type cereals became frequent at different times in different regions.

    Arranz-Otaegui et al. 2016, PNAS

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]M. Heun, R. Schäfer-Pregl, D. Klawan, R. Castagna, M. Accerbi, B. Borghi, F. Salamini. Site of Einkorn Wheat Domestication Identified by DNA Fingerprinting. Science 278(5341): 1312–1314 (1997)
  2. [2]D. Q. Fuller, G. Willcox, R. G. Allaby. Cultivation and domestication had multiple origins: arguments against the core area hypothesis for the origins of agriculture in the Near East. World Archaeology 43(4): 628–652 (2011)
  3. [3]R. G. Allaby, D. Q. Fuller, T. A. Brown. The genetic expectations of a protracted model for the origins of domesticated crops. PNAS 105(37): 13982–13986 (2008)
  4. [4]E. Weiss, M. E. Kislev, A. Hartmann. Autonomous cultivation before domestication. Science 312(5780): 1608–1610 (2006)
  5. [5]K. Tanno, G. Willcox. How fast was wild wheat domesticated?. Science 311(5769): 1886 (2006)
  6. [6]M. A. Zeder. The Origins of Agriculture in the Near East. Current Anthropology 52(S4): S221–S235 (2011)
  7. [7]A. Arranz-Otaegui, S. Colledge, L. Zapata, L. C. Teira-Mayolini, J. J. Ibáñez. Regional diversity on the timing for the initial appearance of cereal cultivation and domestication in southwest Asia. PNAS 113(49): 14001–14006 (2016)
  8. [8]L. Dietrich, J. Meister, O. Dietrich, J. Notroff, et al.. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5): e0215214 (2019)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…