TT
tr

ArticleEditorial draft

After the cold: the end of the Younger Dryas and the Neolithic

The last cold snap of the Ice Age ended c. 9700 BCE, and within a few centuries people were raising pillars at Göbeklitepe. How climate, grassland and wild wheat fit together, and why the 'single birthplace of farming' on Karacadağ is contested.

TT Living History Editorial — draft for author reviewPublished 10 min read

The Younger Dryas is named after a flower. Dryas octopetala, the mountain avens, is a small white-petalled plant of tundra and high mountains. When Scandinavian geologists found its leaves in lake muds lying above layers that recorded a warmer climate, they realised that the retreat of the Ice Age had not been a smooth affair. Late in the thaw, the cold had come back.

That relapse ended about 11,700 years ago. The oldest monumental buildings at Göbeklitepe date to c. 9500 BCE, a couple of centuries later. It is hard to put those two facts side by side without suspecting a connection, and much has been written to supply one. This article sets out what is measured, what is inferred, and where the well-known story of wheat being born on a nearby volcano now stands.

A cold snap with sharp edges

The Younger Dryas lasted from about 12,900 to 11,700 calibrated years before present, c. 10,900–9700 BCE. Its boundaries are fixed most precisely in the Greenland ice cores, where annual layers can be counted and where its end is so clear that geologists use it to define the start of the Holocene, the epoch we live in.1 What makes the episode remarkable is its abruptness. The cooling set in quickly, and the final warming was accomplished, in Greenland, within decades.

The cause most researchers favour is a disturbance of North Atlantic circulation by meltwater from the shrinking North American ice sheet, which weakened the current that carries heat northwards. A rival proposal, that a comet or its fragments struck or exploded over the Earth, has been argued for since 2007 and has been tied by some writers to a carved pillar at Göbeklitepe. It has not won general acceptance among earth scientists, and the pillar reading is rejected by the excavators; the case is laid out in the comet question.

What it did to the Near East

The best long record near the Taş Tepeler region comes from Lake Van, some 350 km to the north-east, whose finely layered sediments preserve pollen, charcoal and chemical signals year by year. During the Younger Dryas the surrounding country was a cold, dry steppe of wormwood and goosefoot. When the cold ended, the change in the mud is sudden: grasses spread, and pistachio follows. Oak woodland, however, came back slowly and took thousands of years to reach its full extent.2

That delay matters for how we picture the landscape the builders knew. The early Holocene hills around Şanlıurfa were not forest. Charcoal and seeds from Göbeklitepe itself point to open country with pistachio and almond trees scattered through grassland, a steppe-forest in the phrase of the botanist Reinder Neef, and the grasses included wild einkorn and wild barley.3 It was a landscape of herds and seed-heads: gazelle, wild ass and aurochs on the hoof, and dense stands of wild cereals ripening in early summer. The game's seasons and resources pages are modelled on that picture.

How harsh the Younger Dryas was for people is less clear than older textbooks suggested. In the southern Levant, the classic account holds that the comparatively settled communities of the Early Natufian broke up into more mobile groups as conditions worsened. Yet a study of the chemistry of gazelle teeth from Natufian sites concluded that the region became cooler but not noticeably drier. Further north, on the upper Tigris, the village of Körtik Tepe was occupied through the later Younger Dryas and into the Holocene, by people who already made elaborately decorated stone vessels. The cold did not empty Upper Mesopotamia. Some of the traditions that flower at Göbeklitepe had roots in it.

The first centuries of the Holocene

Whatever happened during the cold, the visible change comes after it. In the centuries following c. 9700 BCE, communities across the northern Fertile Crescent built substantial, permanent architecture, including large communal buildings at Jerf el Ahmar and other sites on the Syrian Euphrates and the enclosures of Göbeklitepe on the Germuş ridge. UNESCO's listing places the monuments of Göbeklitepe between 9600 and 8200 BCE.4

These were people who used wild cereals heavily. The study of more than 7000 grinding tools from Göbeklitepe showed cereal processing on a large scale, although every identifiable plant from the site is wild.5 On the Euphrates, archaeobotanists led by George Willcox found the weeds of tilled ground among wild-type grain, and concluded that people were cultivating cereals for many centuries before the plants changed form. Cultivation and domestication, on this evidence, are two different things separated by a long interval.

It is tempting to draw a straight line: climate warms, grass spreads, people gather where the grain is, gatherings need feeding, feeding leads to farming. Each link is plausible. None is automatic, and the last two are argued over in feasting, beer and labour and in the question of why here.

The Karacadağ hypothesis

Into this picture, in 1997, came a result that seemed to fix the birthplace of a crop to a single mountain. Karacadağ is a broad basalt volcano between Şanlıurfa and Diyarbakır; its summit lies less than 100 km north-east of Göbeklitepe. Wild einkorn still grows thickly on its stony slopes.

Manfred Heun and colleagues compared DNA fingerprints at 288 marker loci in several hundred lines of wild and cultivated einkorn collected across the Fertile Crescent and beyond. In the resulting family tree the cultivated lines clustered together, and their nearest wild relatives were a group of populations from Karacadağ. The authors concluded that this wild group was the likely progenitor of cultivated einkorn, and pointed to the early farming villages excavated nearby as support.6 Similar studies soon placed the origin of emmer wheat in the same area.

When Göbeklitepe became famous, the coincidence was irresistible. The world's first monuments and the world's first wheat, a few days' walk apart: journalists, and some scholars, joined the dots.

Why a single origin is now doubted

Over the following fifteen years the single-origin reading was challenged on three fronts.

The method. The 1997 tree was built from a type of marker and a clustering technique that group plants by overall similarity. Robin Allaby and Terence Brown argued in 2003 that such trees can make a crop look as if it came from one place even when it did not. In 2008, with Dorian Fuller, they ran computer simulations of crops domesticated several times independently and then mixed by cultivation. The simulated crops very often appeared, in exactly this kind of analysis, to have a single origin.7 A tree that points to Karacadağ shows where the closest surviving wild relatives grow today. It does not by itself show that domestication happened once, or there.

The diversity. A domestication carried out once, from a small sample of wild plants, should leave a genetic bottleneck: the crop should be much less varied than its wild ancestor. Benjamin Kilian and colleagues sequenced 18 loci in 321 wild and 92 domesticated einkorn lines and found no such reduction. They suggested that the wild race ancestral to the crop was taken into cultivation repeatedly, over a wide area.

The archaeology. Counting grains site by site, Ken-ichi Tanno and George Willcox showed that the tough-eared, domesticated type of wheat and barley rose from a small minority to dominance only gradually, over a thousand years and more. In 2011 Fuller, Willcox and Allaby drew the strands together: pre-domestication cultivation is documented in several separate regions, from the southern Levant to the upper Euphrates and Tigris, and different crops appear first in different places. They argued for many parallel beginnings rather than one core area.8

The defenders of the core area have not conceded. Heun, Abbo, Lev-Yadun and Gopher replied in 2012 with a critique of the protracted model, questioning how the archaeobotanical percentages were calculated and insisting that the genetics and the biology of the crops favour a rapid, localised event.

What can be said

The firm points are few and worth stating plainly. The Younger Dryas was real, cold and sharply bounded, and it ended c. 9700 BCE. In eastern Anatolia its end brought grassland first and woodland much later. The monumental building of the Taş Tepeler region begins within a few centuries of that change, in a landscape rich in wild cereals and game. The people who built it processed wild grain in quantity. Morphologically domesticated cereals become clearly visible in the region only later, in the ninth millennium BCE.

Beyond that lie interpretations. That warming caused the monuments is an inference from timing; the same climate change touched many regions that built nothing comparable. That einkorn was domesticated once, on Karacadağ, by the neighbours of Göbeklitepe is a hypothesis that has lost ground since 1997, though the mountain's wild wheat remains part of the story. The fuller argument is set out in where was wheat domesticated?, and the practical consequences for people who ate cereals they had not yet tamed in agriculture.

Footnotes

  1. The dates follow the Greenland ice-core chronology summarised in Rasmussen, S. O. and colleagues 2014, A stratigraphic framework for abrupt climatic changes during the Last Glacial period, Quaternary Science Reviews 106: 14–28. Figures are rounded. ↩

  2. Wick, L., Lemcke, G. and Sturm, M. 2003. The Holocene 13(5): 665–675. ↩

  3. Neef, R. 2003. Overlooking the steppe-forest: a preliminary report on the botanical remains from Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe. Neo-Lithics 2/03: 13–16. ↩

  4. UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Göbekli Tepe, list entry 1572. ↩

  5. Dietrich, L. and colleagues 2019. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5): e0215214. ↩

  6. Heun, M. and colleagues 1997. Site of Einkorn Wheat Domestication Identified by DNA Fingerprinting. Science 278(5341): 1312–1314. ↩

  7. Allaby, R. G., Fuller, D. Q. and Brown, T. A. 2008. The genetic expectations of a protracted model for the origins of domesticated crops. PNAS 105(37): 13982–13986. ↩

  8. Fuller, D. Q., Willcox, G. and Allaby, R. G. 2011. Cultivation and domestication had multiple origins: arguments against the core area hypothesis for the origins of agriculture in the Near East. World Archaeology 43(4): 628–652. ↩

Sources

  1. [1]Manfred Heun, Ralf Schäfer-Pregl, Dieter Klawan, Renato Castagna, Monica Accerbi, Basilio Borghi, Francesco Salamini. Site of Einkorn Wheat Domestication Identified by DNA Fingerprinting. Science 278(5341): 1312–1314. Science (1997)
  2. [2]Sylvi Haldorsen, Hasan Akan, Bahattin Çelik, Manfred Heun. The climate of the Younger Dryas as a boundary for Einkorn domestication. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany 20: 305–318. Springer (2011)
  3. [3]Lucia Wick, Gerry Lemcke, Michael Sturm. Evidence of Lateglacial and Holocene climatic change and human impact in eastern Anatolia: high-resolution pollen, charcoal, isotopic and geochemical records from the laminated sediments of Lake Van, Turkey. The Holocene 13(5): 665–675. SAGE (2003)
  4. [4]Dorian Q. Fuller, George Willcox, Robin G. Allaby. Cultivation and domestication had multiple origins: arguments against the core area hypothesis for the origins of agriculture in the Near East. World Archaeology 43(4): 628–652. Taylor and Francis (2011)
  5. [5]Robin G. Allaby, Dorian Q. Fuller, Terence A. Brown. The genetic expectations of a protracted model for the origins of domesticated crops. PNAS 105(37): 13982–13986. PNAS (2008)
  6. [6]Benjamin Kilian and colleagues. Molecular diversity at 18 loci in 321 wild and 92 domesticate lines reveal no reduction of nucleotide diversity during Triticum monococcum (einkorn) domestication. Molecular Biology and Evolution 24(12): 2657–2668. Oxford University Press (2007)
  7. [7]Manfred Heun, Shahal Abbo, Simcha Lev-Yadun, Avi Gopher. A critical review of the protracted domestication model for Near-Eastern founder crops. Journal of Experimental Botany 63(12): 4333–4341. Oxford University Press (2012)
  8. [8]Laura Dietrich and colleagues. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5): e0215214. PLOS ONE (2019)
  9. [9]Reinder Neef. Overlooking the steppe-forest: a preliminary report on the botanical remains from Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe. Neo-Lithics 2/03: 13–16. ex oriente (2003)
  10. [10]Göbekli Tepe – UNESCO World Heritage Centre. UNESCO (2018)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…