TT
tr

Question 15 · Fringe claim — shown with the mainstream response

Is the comet-impact reading of Pillar 43 credible?

A 2017 paper claimed that the Vulture Stone records a comet strike that triggered the Younger Dryas cold spell. The excavators rejected the reading in the same journal, and the impact itself is disputed by most Earth scientists. This is a fringe idea; here is what it says and why specialists are unconvinced.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • AProponents

    The match between the carvings and star positions is statistically too good to be chance. Göbeklitepe was in part an observatory, and Pillar 43 commemorates a catastrophe remembered for generations.

  • BThe excavation team

    The reading is arbitrary and ignores chronology, building history and the wider iconography. Pillar 43 belongs with Neolithic imagery of death, headless bodies and scavenging birds.

  • CEarth scientists on the impact

    Most researchers who have examined the claimed impact markers find them unreproducible or better explained otherwise. A minority continues to defend the hypothesis, and the argument goes on in the journals.

The stone and the story

Pillar 43 stands in Enclosure D at Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe). Its broad face is crowded with carving: a large vulture with a disc above one wing, other birds, a scorpion, snakes, and near the base a headless man. It is among the most complex compositions at the site, and its nickname, the Vulture Stone, has travelled far beyond archaeology.

In 2017 Martin Sweatman and Dimitrios Tsikritsis, engineers at the University of Edinburgh, published an interpretation of it. They argued that the animals represent star groups, with the scorpion as Scorpius and the vulture as part of Sagittarius, and that the disc is the sun. Because the positions of the stars shift slowly over millennia, such a picture could act as a date stamp. They read the date as 10,950 BC, give or take 250 years. That is close to the onset of the Younger Dryas, a cold period of about 1200 years, and to the date of a comet impact that some researchers believe caused it. The headless man, they suggested, stands for death on a great scale.

The archaeologists' reply

Members of the excavation team answered in the next issue of the same journal. Their response did not rule out interest in the sky at Göbeklitepe. It objected to this reading on several grounds.

  • Chronology. No date from Enclosure D comes near 10,950 BC; the oldest lies 700 to 1000 years later. The memory of an event would have had to survive, unrecorded, for many centuries before being carved.
  • Constellations. Star figures are cultural. There is no reason to suppose that Neolithic hunters grouped the stars as later Mediterranean astronomers did.
  • Selection. A handful of pillars was chosen from more than 60, and reliefs on the narrow sides of Pillar 43 were not considered.
  • Context. Headless bodies, severed heads and scavenging birds are recurring themes of early Neolithic art in the region and are usually connected with funerary rites. The headless man on Pillar 43 is also shown with a clearly emphasised phallus, which sits poorly with a simple image of death.
  • Architecture. Pillars were moved and reused, and the buildings may have had roofs.

A second layer of doubt

The reading needs the comet to have been real. The Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis, introduced by Richard Firestone and colleagues in 2007, holds that fragments of a comet struck or exploded over North America about 12,900 years ago. It has been debated ever since. In 2023 Vance Holliday and co-authors published a long review, titled a "comprehensive refutation", arguing that the claimed impact markers are not reproducible or have other explanations. Supporters, Sweatman among them, published a formal rejection of that review the following year. The majority view in Earth science remains that the Younger Dryas had other causes, chiefly changes in ocean circulation, but the dispute is not closed.

So the comet reading of Pillar 43 rests on two contested claims at once: that the carving is a star map, and that there was an impact to record.

What would settle it?

An undisputed impact layer of the right age, found in sediments in or near the Urfa region, would change the picture. So would radiocarbon dates placing Enclosure D in the eleventh millennium BC. On the iconographic side, a prediction made in advance would count for much: if the method is sound, it should say what a newly excavated pillar ought to show before anyone has seen it.

Do you think the excavators have dismissed the idea too quickly, or the proponents have seen patterns in noise? Set out your reasoning.

Evidence cards

  • Hypothesis

    The claim

    Sweatman and Tsikritsis proposed that the animals on Pillar 43 stand for constellations and that their arrangement gives a date of 10,950 BC, plus or minus 250 years. They linked this to a proposed cometary impact at the start of the Younger Dryas.

    Sweatman and Tsikritsis 2017

  • Counter-evidence

    The dates do not meet

    The proposed date is 700 to 1000 years older than the oldest radiocarbon date so far available for Enclosure D, where the pillar stands. The site's dates mark the end of the Younger Dryas, not its beginning.

    Notroff et al. 2017

  • Counter-evidence

    Whose constellations?

    The reading assumes that hunters in Upper Mesopotamia saw the same star figures later described by Egyptian, Arabian and Greek scholars. The excavators consider that highly unlikely across such a span of time and culture.

    Notroff et al. 2017

  • Counter-evidence

    A pillar taken out of context

    More than 60 T-pillars are known from the site and many carry similar animals; the same imagery appears on small objects across the region. The study used a few selected pillars and overlooked reliefs on the narrow sides of Pillar 43 itself.

    Notroff et al. 2017

  • Counter-evidence

    Moved pillars, perhaps a roof

    Many pillars were reused and no longer stand in their original positions, and the buildings may have been roofed. Both points limit any reading of the enclosures as sky observatories.

    Notroff et al. 2017

  • Counter-evidence

    The impact itself is contested

    The Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis was put forward in 2007. A 2023 review by a large group of specialists concluded that the evidence does not support it; proponents published a rejection of that review in 2024.

    Firestone et al. 2007; Holliday et al. 2023; Sweatman et al. 2024

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]M. B. Sweatman, D. Tsikritsis. Decoding Göbekli Tepe with archaeoastronomy: What does the fox say?. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 17(1): 233–250 (2017)
  2. [2]J. Notroff, O. Dietrich, L. Dietrich, C. L. Tvetmarken, M. Kinzel, J. Schlindwein, D. Sönmez, L. Clare. More than a vulture: A response to Sweatman and Tsikritsis. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 17(2): 57–63 (2017)
  3. [3]More than a vulture: A response to Sweatman and Tsikritsis (summary by the excavation team). DAI, The Tepe Telegrams (2017)
  4. [4]R. B. Firestone, A. West, J. P. Kennett, et al.. Evidence for an extraterrestrial impact 12,900 years ago that contributed to the megafaunal extinctions and the Younger Dryas cooling. PNAS 104(41): 16016–16021 (2007)
  5. [5]V. T. Holliday, T. L. Daulton, P. J. Bartlein, M. B. Boslough, et al.. Comprehensive refutation of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis (YDIH). Earth-Science Reviews 247: 104502 (2023)
  6. [6]M. B. Sweatman, J. L. Powell, A. West. Rejection of Holliday et al.'s alleged refutation of the Younger Dryas impact hypothesis. Earth-Science Reviews 258: 104960 (2024)
  7. [7]M. B. Sweatman. Representations of calendars and time at Göbekli Tepe and Karahan Tepe support an astronomical interpretation of their symbolism. Time and Mind 17(3–4): 191–247 (2024)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…