TT
tr

Question 07 · Contested

Was there astronomical intent?

Several authors claim the enclosures were aligned on Sirius, Deneb or the solstices, or that carvings record constellations. The excavators answer that the buildings were rebuilt, possibly roofed and imprecisely dated, and that no alignment has been demonstrated.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • ADeliberate stellar or solar alignment

    The enclosures were laid out to face a particular star or sunrise, and their orientations can even help date them (Magli; Collins; De Lorenzis and Orofino).

  • BCarvings as a sky record

    The reliefs encode constellations, dates or a calendar (Sweatman and colleagues). Archaeologists working on the site reject this reading; see also the comet-impact question.

  • CNot demonstrated

    Sky-watching was surely part of life, but the architecture as excavated cannot support precise alignment claims, and the proposed targets contradict one another (Notroff, Dietrich, Clare and colleagues).

A reasonable question

People who lived by hunting and gathering knew the sky. The turning of the stars and the swing of the sunrise along the horizon marked the seasons that governed gazelle migrations and ripening grasses. Asking whether the builders of Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) built that knowledge into their monuments is therefore legitimate. The excavators say so themselves, and report that they have worked with archaeoastronomers. Their answer so far is that no connection between the orientation of pillars or enclosures and astronomical phenomena has been identified.

The claims

Several proposals have been published, mostly by authors from outside archaeology.

  • Sirius. Giulio Magli suggested that Enclosures D, C and B were oriented, one after another, to the slowly shifting rising point of Sirius, which had become visible from this latitude not long before.
  • Deneb. Andrew Collins, in popular books, argued that the central pillars look north-west to the setting of Deneb. Alessandro De Lorenzis and Vincenzo Orofino found the Deneb idea workable for some enclosures, at dates different from Collins's, and proposed a sunrise target for Enclosure F and a lunar one for Enclosure A.
  • Carved constellations. Martin Sweatman and Dimitrios Tsikritsis interpreted the animals on Pillar 43 as constellations recording a date around 10,950 BCE, an argument tied to the comet-impact hypothesis.

These proposals do not agree with one another. Sirius lies to the south-east and Deneb to the north-west, and each scheme assigns the same buildings to a different target.

The archaeologists' response

In 2017 the research team published a reply in the journal that had carried Sweatman and Tsikritsis's paper. Their points apply to alignment claims generally. The enclosures are not fully excavated. Many pillars are not in their original positions, because the buildings were modified and pillars were reused. The enclosures may have been roofed. The date proposed for Pillar 43 is many centuries older than the oldest radiocarbon date from Enclosure D. And there is no reason to think Neolithic hunters saw the same constellations as later Egyptian, Arabian or Greek scholars.

What geometry can and cannot show

Formal studies do suggest planning: Haklay and Gopher found a regular geometric relation between Enclosures B, C and D. Planning, however, is not astronomy. A layout can be carefully designed for social or symbolic reasons that have nothing to do with the sky.

What would settle it?

A consistent orientation shared by special buildings at several Taş Tepeler sites, each securely dated and with its original pillar positions established, would be strong evidence. So would an unambiguous depiction of a celestial body in a context that makes its meaning clear. Proof that the enclosures were roofed would weaken observational claims, though not symbolic ones. Where do you draw the line between a sky-aware culture and an observatory? Make your argument, and compare the Astronomy page in the game wiki.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    The sky mattered to foragers

    The research team accepts that observation of the night sky would have been important to Neolithic hunter-gatherers, and says it has consulted archaeoastronomers. So far, it reports, no link between pillar or enclosure orientation and astronomical phenomena has been identified.

    Tepe Telegrams FAQ (DAI)

  • Hypothesis

    Sirius rising

    The physicist Giulio Magli proposed that Enclosures D, C and B were successively oriented to the rising point of Sirius, a bright star that had newly become visible at this latitude as a result of precession.

    Magli 2016, Nexus Network Journal 18

  • Hypothesis

    Deneb setting, and other targets

    Andrew Collins argued that the central pillars face the setting of Deneb in Cygnus. De Lorenzis and Orofino supported a Deneb alignment for some enclosures at different dates and suggested solar and lunar targets for others.

    De Lorenzis & Orofino 2015, Archaeological Discovery 3

  • Hypothesis

    Pillar 43 as a star map

    Sweatman and Tsikritsis read the animals on Pillar 43 as constellations fixing a date near 10,950 BCE. A later paper by Sweatman reads V-shaped marks as a lunisolar calendar.

    Sweatman & Tsikritsis 2017; Sweatman 2024

  • Counter-evidence

    Pillars moved, buildings rebuilt, perhaps roofed

    The excavators point out that many pillars are not in their original positions, the enclosures are the result of multi-phase rebuilding, and they may have been roofed, which would limit any use as observatories.

    Notroff et al. 2017, Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 17(2)

  • Counter-evidence

    Constellations are not universal

    The same response argues that it is highly unlikely Neolithic hunters recognised the star groupings later defined by Egyptian, Arabian and Greek scholars, and that selecting a few carvings from a much larger corpus is arbitrary.

    Notroff et al. 2017

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]J. Notroff, O. Dietrich, L. Clare, L. Dietrich, J. Schlindwein, M. Kinzel, C. Lelek-Tvetmarken, D. Sönmez. More than a vulture: A response to Sweatman and Tsikritsis. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 17(2), 57–63 (2017)
  2. [2]More than a vulture: A response to Sweatman and Tsikritsis – The Tepe Telegrams. German Archaeological Institute (DAI) (2017)
  3. [3]Frequently asked questions – The Tepe Telegrams (Göbekli Tepe research staff). German Archaeological Institute (DAI)
  4. [4]G. Magli. Sirius and the project of the megalithic enclosures at Gobekli Tepe. Nexus Network Journal 18, 337–346 (preprint arXiv:1307.8397) (2016)
  5. [5]A. De Lorenzis, V. Orofino. New Possible Astronomic Alignments at the Megalithic Site of Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. Archaeological Discovery 3, 40–50 (2015)
  6. [6]M. B. Sweatman, D. Tsikritsis. Decoding Göbekli Tepe with archaeoastronomy: what does the fox say?. Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry 17(1), 233–250 (2017)
  7. [7]M. B. Sweatman. Representations of calendars and time at Göbekli Tepe and Karahan Tepe support an astronomical interpretation of their symbolism. Time and Mind 17 (2024)
  8. [8]G. Haklay, A. Gopher. Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 30(2), 343–357 (2020)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…