TT
tr

Question 06 · Contested

Did feasting and beer drive agriculture?

The excavators proposed that feeding and rewarding the builders with feasts, possibly including beer, pushed people towards cultivating cereals. The evidence for large-scale cereal processing is strong; the evidence for beer and for a causal link to farming is not.

Published 2 min read

Competing views

  • AFeasts created the demand

    Monument building required feeding crowds. Meeting that demand, perhaps with beer as an attraction, intensified the use of wild cereals and set cultivation in motion (Dietrich, Notroff, Schmidt; earlier Hayden).

  • BOne factor among many

    Feasting at Göbeklitepe is well supported, but the shift to farming was a long, regional process involving climate, population and local ecology. Feasts may have contributed without being the driver.

  • CCause and effect reversed

    Intensive plant use and semi-settled life came first and made large gatherings and monuments possible. The cereals at Göbeklitepe remain morphologically wild, so the site documents consumption, not domestication.

An old idea with a new site

In 1953 the archaeologist Robert Braidwood asked a group of colleagues, half in jest, whether early cereal growers were after bread or beer. The question never quite went away. When Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) showed that hunter-gatherers had built monuments before they farmed, it returned in a sharper form: could the effort of feeding and motivating builders have pushed people into agriculture?

What the evidence supports

The case for large-scale food preparation is solid. A study of more than 7000 grinding stones, handstones, mortars and pestles, backed by use-wear experiments and phytoliths, shows that cereals were processed in quantity. Animal bones point to intensive gazelle hunting from midsummer to autumn. With no large storage installations identified, the authors argue that food was prepared for prompt consumption and read the seasonal peaks as work feasts: communal meals given in return for labour, a practice well documented by ethnographers.

Geography adds weight. Genetic work by Manfred Heun and colleagues linked domesticated einkorn to wild stands on Karacadağ, a volcanic massif not far to the north-east.

Where the argument thins: beer

The beer evidence is a different matter. Six limestone vessels with capacities of up to 160 litres were found in place, and residues on some gave partly positive results for calcium oxalate, a by-product of mashing and fermenting grain. The excavators have been clear that these results are preliminary. Oxalate can arise in other ways, and no confirmed brewing residue has followed. Claims for still older Natufian beer at Raqefet Cave have likewise been disputed.

The wider picture

Archaeobotanists now describe Near Eastern domestication as protracted. Cultivation of wild plants appears at several places across the Fertile Crescent, and domestic traits such as non-shattering ears spread slowly over many centuries. On that view no single site, and no single motive, started farming. Göbeklitepe may show one regional setting in which demand for cereals was unusually high.

What would settle it?

Three things would help. First, reliable biomarkers for fermentation in the stone vessels, replicated by independent laboratories. Second, well-dated plant remains from the Taş Tepeler sites showing whether cultivation intensified during periods of major building. Third, comparable studies at Karahantepe and Sayburç. Until then: is the feast the engine of the Neolithic or only its most visible party? Argue your side, and see Where was wheat domesticated? for the botanical half of the debate.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    More than 7000 grinding tools

    Use-wear and phytolith analysis of the ground-stone assemblage shows that cereals were processed at Göbeklitepe on a scale unusual for sites of its time.

    Dietrich et al. 2019, PLOS ONE

  • Hypothesis

    Seasonal peaks and no large stores

    Gazelle were hunted in large numbers between midsummer and autumn, and no large storage facilities have been identified. The authors interpret this as food produced for immediate use at large work feasts.

    Dietrich et al. 2019, PLOS ONE

  • Evidence

    Stone vessels of up to 160 litres

    Six large limestone vessels were found in place in PPNB contexts. Grey-black residues on some tested partly positive for calcium oxalate, which can form when grain is soaked, mashed and fermented.

    Dietrich et al. 2012, Antiquity 86

  • Counter-evidence

    The beer evidence is preliminary

    The team itself describes the chemical results as preliminary and not conclusive. Oxalate is not unique to brewing, and no confirmed brewing residue from the site has been published since.

    Dietrich et al. 2012; Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    Einkorn's wild relatives grow nearby

    A DNA fingerprinting study traced domesticated einkorn to wild populations in the Karacadağ mountains of south-eastern Turkey, which the excavators describe as very near to Göbeklitepe.

    Heun et al. 1997, Science 278

  • Counter-evidence

    Domestication was slow and dispersed

    Archaeobotanical work indicates that cereals were cultivated for many centuries across several regions before domestic traits became fixed. That is hard to reconcile with a single centre or a single cause.

    Fuller, Willcox & Allaby 2011, World Archaeology 43

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]O. Dietrich, M. Heun, J. Notroff, K. Schmidt, M. Zarnkow. The role of cult and feasting in the emergence of Neolithic communities. New evidence from Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey. Antiquity 86(333), 674–695 (2012)
  2. [2]L. Dietrich et al.. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5), e0215214 (2019)
  3. [3]O. Dietrich. Out for a beer at the dawn of agriculture – The Tepe Telegrams. German Archaeological Institute (DAI) (2016)
  4. [4]M. Heun et al.. Site of Einkorn Wheat Domestication Identified by DNA Fingerprinting. Science 278(5341), 1312–1314 (1997)
  5. [5]D. Q. Fuller, G. Willcox, R. G. Allaby. Cultivation and domestication had multiple origins: arguments against the core area hypothesis for the origins of agriculture in the Near East. World Archaeology 43(4), 628–652 (2011)
  6. [6]B. Hayden, N. Canuel, J. Shanse. What Was Brewing in the Natufian? An Archaeological Assessment of Brewing Technology in the Epipaleolithic. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 20, 102–150 (2013)
  7. [7]L. Liu et al.. Fermented beverage and food storage in 13,000 y-old stone mortars at Raqefet Cave, Israel: Investigating Natufian ritual feasting. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 21, 783–793 (2018)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…