TT
tr

Question 01 · Open question

Who built Göbeklitepe, and how were they organised?

The builders were hunter-gatherers with no domesticated crops or animals. Whether they were a large seasonal gathering led by ritual specialists or a modest resident community is still argued.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • ASeasonal congregation with ritual leadership

    Mobile bands from across the region met periodically at the hill, built under the guidance of ritual specialists and were bound together by work feasts (Schmidt; Dietrich, Notroff).

  • BA resident village community

    The builders lived on site. Households or kin groups raised and maintained their own buildings over generations, and no large imported workforce is required (Banning; in part Clare, Kinzel).

  • CSeveral groups, one shared tradition

    Distinct social groups, perhaps clans with their own emblem animals, each kept an enclosure while sharing a symbolic language with other Taş Tepeler sites. Organisation was cooperative rather than centrally commanded.

What we can say with confidence

The people who raised the great enclosures of Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) between c. 9500 and 8000 BCE were hunter-gatherers. UNESCO's description says as much, and the excavated record supports it: the animal bones are from wild species, and no domesticated livestock has been found. They had no pottery, no metal, no wheels and no draft animals. What they did have was flint, limestone, timber, rope, and one another.

Everything beyond that is inference. No written word survives, and no burial ground or obvious "chief's house" has been excavated that would show who gave instructions and who followed them.

The classic picture: a gathering of many bands

The site's first excavator, Klaus Schmidt, saw a meeting place. In his reading, groups from a wide region converged on the hill at certain times of year, and the work of quarrying and erecting pillars weighing several tons required more hands than a single band could supply. The research team's own summary speaks of careful planning and coordination, "suggestive of some level of social stratification", and of feasting as the means of rewarding labour. Later studies of the grinding stones and gazelle bones were interpreted as seasonal peaks of activity, consistent with large work feasts.

The carvings add a clue. The imagery is not the same from one enclosure to the next; particular animals dominate particular buildings. The excavators have suggested that different communities may have been responsible for different enclosures.

The revision: neighbours, not pilgrims

Since about 2015, renewed fieldwork has changed the frame. Lee Clare and colleagues report domestic buildings, cisterns cut into the bedrock for rainwater, and tools of everyday life. If people lived on the mound, the builders need not have come from far away. Ted Banning had argued this as early as 2011: in his view the labour estimates were inflated, and a village community could have built everything over generations.

Planning beyond one building

Gil Haklay and Avi Gopher found that the centre points of Enclosures B, C and D fall within about 25–28 cm of the corners of an ideal equilateral triangle. They argue that the three were conceived as one project. The excavators caution that the enclosures were rebuilt repeatedly and that their strict contemporaneity has not been shown, so the geometry is a hypothesis rather than a fact about organisation.

What would settle it?

Three kinds of evidence would move this debate: human remains with isotopic or genetic signatures showing where individuals grew up; tightly dated building sequences showing whether enclosures rose together or one after another; and clear differences, or a clear lack of them, between households. Until then, the question is open. Was this a congregation, a village, or a federation of clans? Pick a position, weigh the evidence cards above, and see how the argument continues in How were the clans persuaded? and Were there specialists?.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    Only wild animals on the menu

    The animal bones from the site come from wild species, above all gazelle and aurochs. No domesticated livestock has been identified, so the builders were hunters, not herders.

    Peters & Schmidt 2004, Anthropozoologica 39

  • Evidence

    Each enclosure favours different animals

    The carved imagery differs from building to building, with one or more animals especially prominent in each. The excavators read this as a possible sign that different groups were responsible for different enclosures.

    Notroff et al. 2017; Peters & Schmidt 2004

  • Hypothesis

    A large workforce gathered from afar

    Klaus Schmidt's team argued that quarrying and raising the pillars exceeded the capacity of a single hunter-gatherer band, and that people from a wide region assembled seasonally, rewarded with feasts.

    Schmidt 2010; Dietrich et al. 2012, Antiquity 86

  • Evidence

    People lived on the mound

    Newer fieldwork reports domestic buildings, rock-cut cisterns and thousands of grinding tools. That points to a resident community rather than an empty sanctuary visited by pilgrims.

    Clare 2020; Dietrich et al. 2019, PLOS ONE

  • Counter-evidence

    Small crews may have been enough

    Ted Banning argued that the labour demands were overestimated and that a modest community could have built the enclosures over time, with no need for an elite directing outsiders.

    Banning 2011, Current Anthropology 52

  • Hypothesis

    A single geometric plan?

    A formal analysis finds that the centre points of Enclosures B, C and D lie close to the corners of an equilateral triangle. If the three were laid out together, that implies planning above the level of one building, but their contemporaneity is not demonstrated.

    Haklay & Gopher 2020, Cambridge Archaeological Journal 30

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]Göbekli Tepe – UNESCO World Heritage Centre. UNESCO (2018)
  2. [2]J. Peters, K. Schmidt. Animals in the symbolic world of Pre-Pottery Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey: a preliminary assessment. Anthropozoologica 39(1), 179–218 (2004)
  3. [3]O. Dietrich, M. Heun, J. Notroff, K. Schmidt, M. Zarnkow. The role of cult and feasting in the emergence of Neolithic communities. New evidence from Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey. Antiquity 86(333), 674–695 (2012)
  4. [4]E. B. Banning. So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East. Current Anthropology 52(5), 619–660 (2011)
  5. [5]L. Clare. Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. A brief summary of research at a new World Heritage Site (2015–2019). e-Forschungsberichte des DAI 2020, Faszikel 2, 81–88 (2020)
  6. [6]L. Dietrich et al.. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5), e0215214 (2019)
  7. [7]G. Haklay, A. Gopher. Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 30(2), 343–357 (2020)
  8. [8]Frequently asked questions – The Tepe Telegrams (Göbekli Tepe research staff). German Archaeological Institute (DAI)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…