TT
tr

Question 04 · Open question

How were pillars of up to ten tons moved without wheels or draft animals?

The quarries lie only a few hundred metres from the enclosures, and an unfinished 7 m pillar still rests in the bedrock. How the stones were hauled and raised is inferred from quarry marks, ethnography and experiment, not from direct traces.

Published 2 min read

Competing views

  • AMany hands, staged as an event

    Pillars were dragged on timber sledges by large gatherings, perhaps hundreds of people, and the hauling itself was a social and ritual occasion supported by feasting (Schmidt, Dietrich, Notroff).

  • BSmall skilled crews

    With levers, ropes, rollers or greased timber runners and short distances, a few dozen people or fewer could have moved most pillars. No extraordinary workforce is implied (Banning).

  • CWe do not know the method

    No sledge, rope, ramp or track has been found. Any reconstruction is an analogy, and different pillars may have been moved in different ways.

The scale of the problem

The tallest pillars standing at Göbeklitepe (Göbekli Tepe) are the central pair of Enclosure D: about 5.5 m high and, by the excavators' estimate, 8 to 10 metric tons each. The people who set them up had no wheels, no metal tools, no pulleys and no animals to pull for them. Yet they did it many times over, and at sister sites across the Taş Tepeler region as well.

What the quarries show

Here the evidence is unusually good, because the source of the stone is known. The mound sits on a limestone plateau, and the quarry areas are on that same plateau. The rock is bedded in banks between 0.6 and 1.5 m thick, divided by natural fault lines. A quarry worker therefore had to cut around a pillar but not beneath it. Channels were pecked out with flint picks to outline the piece; once the natural parting was reached, the block was most probably prised loose with wooden beams and wedges.

Several pieces went wrong and were left where they lay. The most striking is a T-shaped pillar about 7 m long and 1.5 m thick at the edge of the western plateau, with an estimated weight of around 50 tons. A crack or flaw may have doomed it, or, as the excavators dryly note, the project may simply have been too big.

What is not known

For transport itself, direct traces are absent. No sledge, rope or trackway has survived. The distances are short, from under 100 m to roughly 500 m, but the route runs over uneven bedrock. Reconstructions rest on analogy: timber sledges, plant-fibre ropes, levers, and perhaps timber rails or rollers.

Raising the stone

Setting a pillar upright is a separate problem. The central pillars of Enclosure D stand in shallow sockets cut into bedrock pedestals, which seems too little to hold them unaided. That has been used as an argument for supporting timberwork or a roof. How pillars were tipped into place, with earthen ramps, timber frames or rope teams, is again inferred and not observed.

What would settle it?

Full-scale experiments on the local limestone, with replica flint picks and a sledge on the actual terrain, would turn guesses into measured ranges. Use-wear on quarry tools, drag marks on bedrock exposed under the fill, or preserved timber would be better still. How would you move a ten-ton stone 300 metres with rope and wood? Set out your method, and test it against Logistics and Physics in the game wiki.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    Central pillars of 8 to 10 tons

    The two central pillars of Enclosure D stand about 5.5 m high and are estimated at 8 to 10 metric tons each. The surrounding pillars are smaller, around 4 m.

    Dietrich, Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    The quarry is next door

    The limestone plateau around the mound was the quarry. Haulage distances were short: under 100 m at best and about 500 m at worst.

    Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    The unfinished 7 m pillar

    A T-shaped pillar about 7 m long and 1.5 m thick lies unfinished at the edge of the western plateau. Its weight is estimated at around 50 metric tons; why it was abandoned is unknown.

    Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    Naturally bedded limestone

    The local limestone occurs in banks 0.6 to 1.5 m thick, separated by natural fault lines. Workers cut channels around a pillar with flint picks and then, most probably, levered it off the bed with wooden beams and wedges.

    Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Hypothesis

    Sledges and hundreds of haulers

    An early twentieth-century account from Nias, Indonesia, records 525 men hauling a megalith of about 4 cubic metres over 3 km in three days on a wooden sledge. The excavators use it as an analogy for sledge transport.

    Schröder 1917, cited in Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Counter-evidence

    Crowds are not the same as necessity

    On Sumba, stone dragging is a ritual that calls for many participants as witnesses, so ethnographic head counts overstate the labour strictly required. Banning argued that small crews could have moved all but the largest pillars.

    Hoskins 1986, cited in Tepe Telegrams 2016; Banning 2011

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]O. Dietrich. How did they do it? Making and moving monoliths at Göbekli Tepe – The Tepe Telegrams. German Archaeological Institute (DAI) (2016)
  2. [2]Göbekli Tepe – UNESCO World Heritage Centre. UNESCO (2018)
  3. [3]K. Schmidt. Göbekli Tepe – the Stone Age Sanctuaries. New results of ongoing excavations with a special focus on sculptures and high reliefs. Documenta Praehistorica 37, 239–256 (2010)
  4. [4]E. B. Banning. So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East. Current Anthropology 52(5), 619–660 (2011)
  5. [5]E. E. W. Schröder. Nias: ethnographische, geographische en historische aanteekeningen en studiën. Brill, Leiden (1917)
  6. [6]J. Hoskins. So My Name Shall Live: Stone-Dragging and Grave-Building in Kodi, West Sumba. Bijdragen tot de Taal-, Land- en Volkenkunde 142(1), 31–51 (1986)
  7. [7]J. Notroff, O. Dietrich, K. Schmidt. Building Monuments, Creating Communities. Early monumental architecture at Pre-Pottery Neolithic Göbekli Tepe. In J. Osborne (ed.), Approaching Monumentality in Archaeology, SUNY Press, 83–105 (2014)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…