TT
tr

Question 10 · Open question

Were there specialists: carvers, knappers, ritual experts?

The reliefs look like the work of trained hands, and the excavators have long spoken of specialised crafts. But skill is not the same as a profession, and no workshop or craftsman's grave has been found.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • ASupported specialists

    Carving at this level needed long training, so some people were freed from getting food for at least part of the year and fed by others.

  • BSkilled but part-time

    As among recent foragers, a few gifted individuals carved, knapped or led rites when needed and otherwise hunted and gathered like everyone else.

  • CRitual knowledge as the real specialism

    The scarce resource was not manual skill but knowing the stories, signs and procedures. Experts in that knowledge directed the work.

Skill is visible; status is not

Stand in front of the high-relief predator on Pillar 27, which Klaus Schmidt called a masterpiece of stonemasonry, and the question answers itself: whoever made this had done it before. The harder question is what kind of person that was. A specialist in the strict sense is someone relieved of producing food because others value what they do instead. Archaeologists usually look for workshops, tool kits buried with their owners, or houses that differ from their neighbours. At Göbeklitepe none of these has been published.

The case for specialists

The excavation team's argument runs from the product back to the producer. The reliefs follow a canon. The same animals are drawn the same way, with the same conventions, on pillar after pillar. Moving and raising a monolith might be done quickly by a crowd, but the carving implies apprenticeship. From there the team suggests that part of the population may have been set free from subsistence, at least seasonally, and looked after by the rest.

Other strands point the same way. The grinding stones are standardised. The flint industry, with its long regular blades struck from carefully prepared cores, is the kind that modern knappers find demanding to reproduce. The surrounding limestone plateau preserves quarry areas where pillars were cut free, among them unfinished pieces left in the rock. And small plaques carry sign combinations that someone, presumably, knew how to read.

Ritual experts

The third category in the title is the hardest. Imagery of masked or dancing figures, cranes with human-like legs, and the careful staging of buildings make it reasonable to think that some people knew more than others about what to do and when. Lee Clare has proposed that storytellers, hunters and ritual experts were the pools from which leading figures emerged. The proposal is deliberately cautious: it speaks of "invisible" decision-makers because nothing excavated so far identifies one.

The geometric analysis of Haklay and Gopher adds a different kind of expert, a planner. If three enclosures really share one design, somebody held that design in mind. Critics reply that the buildings have long and separate construction histories, and that a pattern found on a plan may not have existed on the ground at any single moment.

What would settle it?

A flint or limestone workshop in primary position, with its waste, would show how concentrated production was. Burials with craft tools, or skeletons with the muscle markings and injuries of repetitive stone working, would point to individuals. Study of the reliefs for individual "hands", as is done for painted pottery, could show whether five carvers were at work or fifty.

Does excellence need a class of specialists, or only talent and time? Tell us where you stand and why.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    A learned canon

    Uniform types, a coherent style and precise execution of the reliefs point to a fixed repertoire of motifs and techniques that had to be taught. The excavators take this as a hint of highly specialised crafts.

    DAI Tepe Telegrams 2017; Schmidt 2010

  • Evidence

    Standardised grinding tools

    Use-wear and experimental study of the grinding equipment found that the tools were standardised and efficient. Standardisation shows shared know-how; it does not by itself show full-time makers.

    Dietrich et al. 2019, PLOS ONE

  • Hypothesis

    Planned geometry?

    A formal analysis proposed that Enclosures B, C and D were laid out as one geometric design, which would imply someone who planned. The argument assumes the three buildings were conceived together, which has not been demonstrated stratigraphically.

    Haklay and Gopher 2020

  • Hypothesis

    Signs for the initiated

    Decorated plaques and shaft straighteners repeat combinations of signs known from the pillars and from other sites. The team suggests they stored knowledge intelligible at least to initiated specialists; this is an interpretation.

    DAI Tepe Telegrams 2017

  • Hypothesis

    Storytellers, hunters, ritual experts

    A recent synthesis argues that influential persons existed but left no direct trace, and names three groups from which they could have come. The case rests on imagery, including a life-size boar statue found in Building D.

    Clare 2024

  • Counter-evidence

    No primary contexts

    Most special objects come from fill, not from where they were made or used, so it cannot be shown who owned or worked them. No dedicated workshop and no burial marked out as a craftsperson's has been published from the site.

    DAI Tepe Telegrams 2017

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]Beginning social complexity during the Early Neolithic of Upper Mesopotamia: a view from Göbekli Tepe. DAI, The Tepe Telegrams (2017)
  2. [2]K. Schmidt. Göbekli Tepe – the Stone Age Sanctuaries. New results of ongoing excavations with a special focus on sculptures and high reliefs. Documenta Praehistorica 37: 239–256 (2010)
  3. [3]L. Dietrich, J. Meister, O. Dietrich, J. Notroff, et al.. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5): e0215214 (2019)
  4. [4]G. Haklay, A. Gopher. Geometry and Architectural Planning at Göbekli Tepe, Turkey. Cambridge Archaeological Journal 30(2): 343–357 (2020)
  5. [5]L. Clare. Inspired individuals and charismatic leaders: Hunter-gatherer crisis and the rise and fall of invisible decision-makers at Göbeklitepe. Documenta Praehistorica 51: 6–43 (2024)
  6. [6]J. Woodburn. Egalitarian Societies. Man 17(3): 431–451 (1982)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…