TT
tr

Question 09 · Open question

How were roughly a hundred scattered clans persuaded to cooperate?

Building Göbeklitepe needed hundreds of hands, yet no trace of a chief or a state. Feasts, shared ritual, marriage ties and prestige are the usual candidates. Most of this is model; less of it is evidence.

Published 3 min read

Competing views

  • AWork feasts

    Hosts drew labour with meat, cereal food and probably fermented drink. Help was voluntary, time-limited and paid for on the spot in hospitality.

  • BShared ritual and belief

    A common world of images and ceremonies made strangers into fellow participants. The buildings were the purpose of the gathering, not just its product.

  • CPrestige and persuasive individuals

    Storytellers, hunters or ritual experts competed for standing and carried others with them. Monuments were costly signals of a group's strength and reliability.

  • DA resident community

    The builders were largely local and worked in small increments over centuries. Little regional recruitment was needed.

First, a word about the number

"A hundred clans" is not an archaeological finding. It is the premise of the game that accompanies this site (see the dev diary and the clans page), a round figure chosen to make the coordination problem playable. Nobody knows how many groups were involved, what they called themselves, or whether "clan" is even the right word. What archaeology does offer is a real puzzle of the same shape: people without kings, writing or draught animals repeatedly did something that needed many more hands than one band could supply.

What the ground actually shows

The firmest evidence concerns food and effort. The excavators estimate that the monumental buildings required a workforce of hundreds. The site has yielded an unusual quantity of grinding stones, phytoliths that confirm heavy cereal processing, and bones from gazelle taken mainly between midsummer and autumn. No large storage facilities have turned up. Food seems to have been prepared in bulk and eaten at once.

From this the German Archaeological Institute team built the work-feast model: hosts offer plenty of food and drink, guests give labour, and nobody owes anybody afterwards. The 2012 paper that launched the idea also proposed beer brewed from wild cereals. The feasting pattern is well supported; the beer remains a plausible suggestion and no more.

Where the models begin

Everything beyond the food is inference.

  • Ritual. Similar signs turn up on pillars, stone vessels and small plaques at Göbeklitepe and at contemporary sites across Upper Mesopotamia. A shared symbolic world would make cooperation easier. Whether it caused the cooperation or resulted from it cannot be read from the stones.
  • Marriage. Ethnographically, foragers marry outside their own band, and regular gatherings are where partners are found. At Nevalı Çori, isotopes and ancient DNA indicate mobility and a diverse gene pool in the early PPNB. That is compatible with exogamy. It is not proof of a marriage fair on the hill.
  • Costly signalling. A group that can raise a five-metre pillar and feed its helpers advertises that it is a partner worth having. The logic is sound and the theory respectable, but it explains almost any monument anywhere, which is also its weakness.

Who did the persuading?

No burial, house or object at Göbeklitepe marks out a chief. Lee Clare has recently argued that decision-makers existed but are archaeologically invisible, and that they may have emerged from among storytellers, hunters and ritual experts. That is an interpretation of imagery, not a discovery of persons. An alternative reading holds that nobody persuaded anybody: obligations of kinship and reciprocity did the work, as they do in many societies without leaders.

What would settle it?

Three kinds of data would move the debate: isotope and ancient-DNA studies of people buried at the Taş Tepeler sites, to see who came from where and who married whom; tight dating of single building phases, to learn how much was built in one go; and sourcing of food remains, to show whether guests brought provisions or hosts supplied them.

Which mechanism do you find most convincing, and what would you expect to find in the ground if it were true? Make your case.

Evidence cards

  • Evidence

    A workforce of hundreds

    The excavators argue that quarrying, moving and raising the pillars would have needed hundreds of people even by conservative estimates. This is an engineering estimate, not a head count.

    Dietrich et al. 2019, PLOS ONE

  • Evidence

    Food for immediate use, on a large scale

    More than 7000 grinding tools were analysed, and gazelle were hunted in bulk between midsummer and autumn, yet no large storage facilities have been found. The team reads these seasonal peaks as work feasts.

    Dietrich et al. 2019; Lang et al. 2013

  • Hypothesis

    Each building, its own animal

    Snakes prevail in Enclosure A, foxes in B, boars in C, and birds are prominent in D. The excavators suggest that different groups may stand behind different buildings; the nature of those groups is left open.

    Peters and Schmidt 2004; DAI Tepe Telegrams 2016

  • Evidence

    Mobility and a mixed gene pool at Nevalı Çori

    Strontium isotopes and genomes from nearby Nevalı Çori point to mobility and a diverse gene pool in the early PPNB. That fits wide marriage networks but does not show how marriages were arranged, and it is not Göbeklitepe.

    Wang et al. 2023, PNAS

  • Hypothesis

    Costly signalling

    Signalling theory predicts that wasteful, hard-to-fake displays such as monuments and lavish feasts can build reputation and trust between groups. It is a general model borrowed from behavioural ecology and has not been tested against the site.

    Bliege Bird and Smith 2005

  • Counter-evidence

    Perhaps fewer people, over a longer time

    Domestic activities, cisterns and rebuilding phases suggest that people lived at the site and that buildings grew over generations. If so, far fewer hands were needed at any one moment, and the persuasion problem shrinks.

    Banning 2011; Clare 2020; Kinzel and Clare 2020

Positions (0)

Post your own answer or argument. Members vote and rate; the position with the highest score rises to the top.

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…

Sources

  1. [1]O. Dietrich, M. Heun, J. Notroff, K. Schmidt, M. Zarnkow. The role of cult and feasting in the emergence of Neolithic communities. New evidence from Göbekli Tepe, south-eastern Turkey. Antiquity 86(333): 674–695 (2012)
  2. [2]L. Dietrich, J. Meister, O. Dietrich, J. Notroff, et al.. Cereal processing at Early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, southeastern Turkey. PLOS ONE 14(5): e0215214 (2019)
  3. [3]C. Lang, J. Peters, N. Pöllath, K. Schmidt, G. Grupe. Gazelle behaviour and human presence at early Neolithic Göbekli Tepe, south-east Anatolia. World Archaeology 45(3): 410–429 (2013)
  4. [4]X. Wang, E. Skourtanioti, M. Benz, J. Gresky, et al.. Isotopic and DNA analyses reveal multiscale PPNB mobility and migration across Southeastern Anatolia and the Southern Levant. PNAS 120(4): e2210611120 (2023)
  5. [5]R. Bliege Bird, E. A. Smith. Signaling theory, strategic interaction, and symbolic capital. Current Anthropology 46(2): 221–248 (2005)
  6. [6]L. Clare. Inspired individuals and charismatic leaders: Hunter-gatherer crisis and the rise and fall of invisible decision-makers at Göbeklitepe. Documenta Praehistorica 51: 6–43 (2024)
  7. [7]E. B. Banning. So Fair a House: Göbekli Tepe and the Identification of Temples in the Pre-Pottery Neolithic of the Near East. Current Anthropology 52(5): 619–660 (2011)
  8. [8]Emblematic signs? On the iconography of animals at Göbekli Tepe. DAI, The Tepe Telegrams (2016)
ShareXFacebookWhatsApp

Related

No ratings yet
Rate this

Comments (0)

**bold**, *italic*, [link](https://…), > quote

Loading…